Home Case Laws GST demand quashed as court held that bunching of show cause notices...

GST demand quashed as court held that bunching of show cause notices for multiple financial years violates Sections 73/74 and undermines taxpayer rights

0
444

Case Summary

Case Title: Ms R A and Co v. The Additional Commissioner of Central Taxes
Court: Madras High Court
Petition No.: W.P. No. 17239 of 2025 with W.M.P. No. 19530 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 21.07.2025
Category of Dispute: Validity of “bunching” of Show Cause Notices – Input Tax Credit & Tax Demand
Relevant Sections: Sections 73, 74, 128, 136, 138 of the CGST Act, 2017; Articles 14, 19(1)(g) & 265 of the Constitution

Facts (Paras 2.1 – 2.9)

The petitioner, a partnership firm, challenged the order of the tax department which raised a demand of ₹30.13 crore by issuing a single show cause notice covering six financial years (2017–18 to 2022–23). The petitioner argued that the GST Act prescribes issuance of notices separately for each financial year under Sections 73 and 74. By bunching multiple years into one notice at the fag end of limitation, the petitioner was deprived of sufficient opportunity to gather documents and defend its case. Further, clubbing years prejudiced rights relating to compounding under Section 138 and availing of amnesty schemes for specific years. Reliance was placed on the Titan Company Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner (Madras HC, 2024) and State of J&K v. Caltex (India) Ltd. (AIR 1966 SC 1350).


Questions (Para 5)

Whether issuance of a single show cause notice and passing of one composite assessment order covering multiple financial years is permissible under GST law?


Observations (Paras 6 – 27)

The Court examined Sections 73 and 74 in detail. These provisions envisage issuance of notice for a “tax period,” which is defined under Section 2(106) as the period for which a return is required (monthly or annually). Thus, SCNs can only be based on either monthly returns or an annual return of a single year, not beyond. Each financial year is an independent unit with distinct limitation periods of 3 years (Section 73) or 5 years (Section 74). Clubbing multiple years frustrates statutory safeguards and causes undue hardship, particularly where taxpayers wish to settle or contest only certain years.

The Court relied on Titan Company Ltd. (Mad HC) which had already disapproved bunching of SCNs, and Tharayil Medicals (Kerala HC) which held that composite notices defeat limitation safeguards and can amount to colourable exercise of power. The Court held that “any period” in Sections 73/74 means “tax period” (monthly/annual) and not multiple financial years. Thus, bunching SCNs across years was ultra vires.


Judgment (Paras 28–29)

The Court quashed the impugned order in original which clubbed six years into a single demand. It held:

  1. SCNs must be issued only for the relevant tax period (monthly/annual).

  2. No SCN can cover more than one financial year.

  3. The department acted without jurisdiction in passing a composite order.
    Accordingly, the writ petition was allowed, with the impugned demand and penalty set aside.


Table: Cases Referred

Case Court Citation / Year Verdict
Titan Company Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of GST & Central Excise Madras HC (2024) 15 Centax 118 (Mad) Held that bunching of SCNs across years is impermissible; each year has separate limitation.
W.A. Nos. 2389 & 1397 of 2024 Madras HC (DB) 2025 Directed department to pass separate orders per year with a minimum 4-week gap.
State of J&K v. Caltex (India) Ltd. SC AIR 1966 SC 1350 Each assessment year is separate; items can be split and taxed distinctly.
Tharayil Medicals v. State Tax Officer Kerala HC 2025 Composite SCNs for multiple years are invalid; each year requires independent notice.

Between Fine Lines

For taxpayers, this judgment is a safeguard: GST authorities cannot bundle multiple financial years into one notice to extend limitation or compel composite payments. Each year must be assessed separately, ensuring that businesses retain flexibility to contest or settle liabilities year-wise, and avail amnesty or compounding schemes without being forced into an “all-or-nothing” settlement.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY