Case Summary
Case Title: Shreeji Developers v. State of Gujarat
Court: High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 15930 of 2024 (with SCA No. 15934 of 2024)
Judgment Date: 12/02/2025
Category of Dispute: GST Demand – mismatch between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B
Relevant Sections: Sections 37, 39, 73, 75(4), 107 of the CGST Act, 2017
Facts (Paras 5–15)
The petitioner, a registered partnership firm under GST, provided construction services. In FY 2019–20, its accountant mistakenly reported outward supplies twice in GSTR-1 (once on receipt of advances and again on issuing invoices), though tax was paid correctly once in GSTR-3B. The mismatch led to a notice under Form ASMT-10 (13.07.2021). The petitioner replied via ASMT-11 (20.09.2021), explaining the duplication and reconciling in the annual return (GSTR-9). Despite this, the department issued a SCN under Section 73 (21.03.2022, repeated 01.04.2023) and passed an OIO dated 12.05.2023 ignoring the reconciliation. The petitioner could not file appeal in time due to consultant’s health issues; the appeal filed in March 2024 was dismissed by the appellate authority as time-barred under Section 107(4).
Questions before the Court
-
Whether a mere mismatch between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B, arising from duplication error, can sustain demand under Section 73 without establishing short-payment of tax?
-
Whether passing an order without granting proper opportunity of hearing under Section 75(4) is valid?
-
Whether dismissal of appeal solely on limitation precludes the High Court from exercising writ jurisdiction?
Observations (Paras 16–27)
The Court noted that jurisdiction under Section 73 arises only when there is non-payment or short-payment of tax. Here, duplication in GSTR-1 was reconciled in GSTR-9 and substantiated by reply in ASMT-11. The authority brushed aside this reply, issued SCN under Section 73 without DRC-01A, and passed OIO without affording hearing—contrary to Section 75(4) which mandates hearing. The Court emphasized that mere reliance on GSTR-1 without considering reconciliation or actual tax liability is arbitrary.
Judgment (Paras 28–29)
The High Court quashed the impugned SCN and OIO, holding that the proceedings were without jurisdiction and in violation of natural justice. The matter was remanded to respondent authority to pass a fresh de novo order after granting opportunity of hearing, within 12 weeks.
Table: Cases / Provisions Referred
| Case / Provision | Context | Court’s View |
|---|---|---|
| Section 73 CGST Act | Invoked for demand on mismatch between GSTR-1 & GSTR-3B | Not sustainable unless short-payment is established |
| Section 75(4) CGST Act | Mandates personal hearing | Violated; OIO passed without hearing |
| Section 107(4) CGST Act | Appeal delay condonation | Appellate authority rightly rejected; HC exercised writ powers |
| Sections 37 & 39 CGST Act | Filing of GSTR-1 & GSTR-3B | Dept argued petitioner should have rectified in GSTR-1; HC rejected |
Between Fine Lines
For businesses, this judgment underscores that mismatch between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B cannot by itself justify tax demand unless actual short-payment is proven. Authorities must also comply with Section 75(4) by granting a hearing. Taxpayers should ensure timely reconciliation and rectification in statutory returns, but they can seek judicial relief if procedural fairness is denied.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




