Case Details
-
Title: GST demand quashed as order passed without considering reply and hearing opportunity
-
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Chief Justice’s Court)
-
Case No.: Writ Tax No. 622 of 2025
-
Petitioner: Regency Hospital Limited
-
Respondents: Union of India & Others
-
Date of Judgment: 06.03.2025
-
Bench: Hon’ble Arun Bhansali, CJ and Hon’ble Kshitij Shailendra, J.
-
Provision Involved: Section 74, CGST Act, 2017
-
Category: GST Demand / Natural Justice
Facts (Paras 1–5)
The petitioner hospital was issued show cause notices under Section 74 of the CGST Act for non-payment of GST on sale of medicines to patients and on packaged treatment for the period July 2017–March 2018 to April 2021–March 2022. It filed a detailed reply on 30.08.2024 (acknowledged on portal). The petitioner also sought a personal hearing, but the GST portal did not allow the request. Authorities later claimed to have sent reminders for personal hearing in November and December 2024, but these were dispatched to an old email ID that had already been changed and intimated. Consequently, the petitioner could not appear. Despite this, the impugned order dated 15.01.2025 was passed, recording that no reply was filed and no hearing was availed.
Questions (Issues) (Paras 2–6)
-
Whether the order under Section 74 could be sustained when the petitioner had in fact filed a reply that was ignored in the impugned order?
-
Whether sending hearing notices to an abandoned email address could constitute valid service, thereby justifying the absence of petitioner’s representation?
-
Whether violation of natural justice principles rendered the demand order unsustainable?
Observations (Paras 7–13)
The Court noted that although the department argued that repeated notices were issued for hearing, it admitted that a reply to the show cause notice was indeed filed (Annexure-6). The adjudicating authority’s statement that “no reply was filed” reflected non-application of mind. The Court also found that the email address used for hearing notices was outdated and had been replaced with a new one under due intimation. Sending notices to an abandoned address could not be considered valid service. The adjudication order was therefore passed without considering the reply on record and without granting a real opportunity of personal hearing. This was a clear violation of principles of natural justice.
Judgment (Paras 13–15)
The High Court quashed the order dated 15.01.2025 and the consequent demand, holding that the same could not be sustained. The matter was remanded back to the adjudicating authority to provide a proper opportunity of hearing and decide afresh in accordance with law. The petitioner was directed to appear within one week with a copy of this order, whereupon the authority was to fix a hearing date.
Case Law Table
| Case Referred | Court’s Verdict / Principle |
|---|---|
| Present Case (Regency Hospital Ltd. v. UOI) | Order quashed as reply was ignored and notices were wrongly sent to abandoned email ID; matter remanded with hearing directions. |
(No other precedents specifically cited in this judgment.)
Between Fine Lines
For trade and industry, this judgment reinforces that orders passed without considering replies or served on outdated communication channels are unsustainable. Taxpayers must ensure updated contact details are formally recorded, and authorities are obligated to apply their mind to replies filed and provide genuine opportunities of hearing before confirming demands.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




