Case: M/s S.P. Singla Constructions Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: Patna High Court
Petition No.: CWJC No. 15748 of 2024
Judgment Date: 27.02.2025
Category of Dispute: GST Demand – Violation of Natural Justice (Personal Hearing)
Relevant Sections: Section 73, Section 75(4), Section 61 CGST/BGST Act, Rule 99 CGST/BGST Rules, Section 168A CGST Act
Facts (Paras 2–6, 14–15)
The petitioner, M/s S.P. Singla Constructions Pvt. Ltd., challenged a demand order under Section 73 of the CGST/BGST Act for FY 2019–20 amounting to over ₹16 crores (IGST + CGST + SGST). The demand was raised vide DRC-07 dated 27.08.2024 without following due process. The petitioner argued that:
-
The demand was time-barred as per Section 73(10).
-
Notification No. 56/2023-CT dated 28.12.2023 extending time was ultra vires Section 168A.
-
No proper personal hearing was given under Section 75(4).
-
Pre-show cause notice in Form DRC-01A was not issued.
-
Demand was passed without ASMT-10 under Rule 99 read with Section 61.
Particularly, the SCN fixed 05.06.2024 as date of hearing but required reply by 14.06.2024 – thus hearing preceded the reply.
Questions Before the Court (Paras 11–13)
-
Whether extension of limitation under Notification No. 56/2023 was valid?
-
Whether the demand order complied with Section 75(4) requiring opportunity of personal hearing before adverse order?
-
Whether absence of personal hearing rendered the demand void?
Observations (Paras 12–17)
-
The challenge to extension notifications (No. 13/2022 & 56/2023) already failed in M/s Barhonia Engicon Pvt. Ltd. (CWJC 4180/2024, decided 27.11.2024). Hence, Court did not reopen that issue.
-
The sole issue was compliance with Section 75(4). The statute mandates that if any adverse decision is contemplated, notice of personal hearing must be given even without specific request.
-
In this case, the hearing was fixed before reply was due, contrary to law.
-
State claimed further notices were given, but petitioner’s rejoinder and GST portal screenshot disproved it. No proof of such notices was filed.
-
Hence, the demand order was held in violation of Section 75(4).
Judgment (Paras 17–19)
The Court quashed the demand order for breach of natural justice and remanded the matter to the Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Patna. The Court directed:
-
Fresh hearing to be given on 06.03.2025 at 11 AM.
-
Order to be passed within one month thereafter.
-
Writ allowed to the extent of violation of Section 75(4).
Table of Earlier Cases Referred
| Case | Court & Citation | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| M/s Barhonia Engicon Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (CWJC No. 4180/2024, Patna HC, decided 27.11.2024) | Patna High Court | Held that under Section 75(4), opportunity of hearing is a statutory mandate. Even if no request is made, if adverse order is contemplated, notice of hearing must be issued. Challenge to extension of time notifications under Section 168A failed. |
Between Fine Lines
For industry, this case reinforces that GST demand orders are void if passed without granting proper opportunity of hearing after reply. Fixing a hearing before the reply date or issuing vague references on the portal is not sufficient. Taxpayers should carefully check compliance with Section 75(4) and challenge any orders passed in violation.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




