Home Case Laws GST demand quashed as summary of show cause notice under Form DRC-01...

GST demand quashed as summary of show cause notice under Form DRC-01 was held insufficient to initiate proceedings without a proper statutory notice under Section 73(1)

0
373

Case Reference

MS DNA Agrotech Private Limited v. State of Assam & Ors
Gauhati High Court
WP(C)/6983/2024
Category: Input Tax Credit / Demand & Recovery (Section 73, Rule 142)
Date of Judgment: 05.02.2025
Relevant Provisions: Section 73 & 75 of the CGST/AGST Act, 2017; Rule 142 of CGST/AGST Rules, 2017

Facts (Paras 2–4)

The petitioner, engaged in trading fertilizers under GST registration, challenged an order dated 30.12.2023 passed under Section 73 of the AGST Act. The grievance was that no proper and prior show cause notice (SCN) under Section 73(1) was issued. Instead, only a Summary of SCN in Form GST DRC-01 with an “Attachment to Determination of Tax” was served. The petitioner contended this violated the mandate of Section 73(1) read with Rule 142.


Questions before the Court (Para 7)

  1. Whether summary in Form DRC-01 suffices as a valid SCN under Section 73(1)?

  2. Whether attachment to determination of tax can substitute a SCN?

  3. Whether orders passed under Section 73(9) without hearing comply with Section 75(4) and principles of natural justice?


Observations (Paras 8–12)

The Court relied on its earlier common judgment dated 26.09.2024 (WP(C) 3912/2024 batch) which had laid down:

  • A summary in Form DRC-01 is not a substitute for a proper SCN.

  • Statements under Section 73(3) cannot replace SCNs under Section 73(1).

  • Orders under Section 73(9) must be preceded by compliance with SCN and hearing requirements.

  • Non-issuance of a proper SCN vitiates the entire proceedings.

The Court emphasized that compliance with Section 73(1)–(11) and Rule 142(1) is a condition precedent for a valid order. Absence of a proper SCN renders the order invalid.


Judgment (Paras 12–15)

The Gauhati High Court held that the impugned order dated 30.12.2023 was unsustainable in law and quashed it. However, liberty was granted to the tax authorities to initiate fresh proceedings de novo under Section 73 by issuing a valid SCN, in line with the earlier batch judgment dated 26.09.2024.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court Ratio
Batch of Writs (WP(C) 3912/2024 & Ors, Judgment dated 26.09.2024) Gauhati HC Held that summary in Form DRC-01 cannot substitute a proper SCN under Section 73(1); orders passed without SCN and hearing violate Section 75(4) and natural justice; such orders are liable to be quashed, but liberty can be given to issue fresh SCNs.

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this judgment reinforces that a proper statutory show cause notice is mandatory before any GST demand order under Section 73. Mere service of a summary in Form DRC-01 or attachments cannot initiate proceedings. Any demand without compliance with Section 73(1) and natural justice is void. Traders can challenge such defective proceedings successfully, though the department retains liberty to issue fresh SCNs.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY