Home Case Laws GST demand quashed as transfer of leasehold rights was held to be...

GST demand quashed as transfer of leasehold rights was held to be transfer of immovable property and not supply of service

0
311

Case Summary

Case Title: Dhiraj Can Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad
Petition No.: Special Civil Application No. 3596 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 04 July 2025
Relevant Section(s): Section 73, Section 7(1)(a), Section 9 of CGST/SGST Act; Clause 5(b) of Schedule II; Clause 5 of Schedule III
Category: Classification / Taxability of assignment of leasehold rights under GST

Facts (Paras 1–2.4)

The petitioner was allotted an industrial plot by Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC) in 1982. In 2020, it sought and obtained approval for transfer of leasehold rights to M/s Acquire Chemicals, for which it received ₹75 lakhs. The petitioner did not charge GST on the assignment deed. Later, the department issued summons and a show cause notice demanding ₹13.5 lakhs GST, alleging the transaction amounted to taxable supply of services under heading 9972. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demand through an order under Section 73 dated 29.08.2024.


Questions for Consideration

Whether the assignment of leasehold rights by the petitioner to a third party amounts to a taxable supply of services under GST, or whether it constitutes a transfer of immovable property outside GST scope.


Observations (Paras 3–6)

The Court noted that an identical issue had been decided in Gujarat Chamber of Commerce v. Union of India (SCA No. 11345 of 2023). That ruling had elaborately discussed the distinction between supply of services in respect of lease and assignment of leasehold rights. The Court emphasized that while initial allotment by GIDC on long lease may amount to supply of service, subsequent assignment of leasehold rights is akin to transfer/sale of immovable property.
The Court cited Sections 7, 9, Schedule II and III, and relied on precedents including Gopal Saran v. Satya Narayana (1989) and Byramjee Jeejeebhoy v. State of Maharashtra (1965), noting that assignment extinguishes all rights of the assignor, thereby constituting absolute transfer of immovable property. The GST Council’s discussions and legislative intent further supported the view that GST is not leviable on transfer of land or immovable property.


Judgement (Paras 6–8)

The High Court held that the assignment by way of sale and transfer of leasehold rights of GIDC plots amounts to transfer of immovable property. Such transactions fall outside the scope of Section 7 of GST Act and hence are not subject to levy of GST under Section 9. Consequently, the impugned demand order, show cause notice, and Form DRC-07 were quashed and set aside. The petition succeeded with no order as to costs.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court Citation / Details Verdict
Gujarat Chamber of Commerce v. Union of India Gujarat HC SCA No. 11345 of 2023 Held that assignment of leasehold rights is transfer of immovable property, not supply under GST
Gopal Saran v. Satya Narayana Supreme Court (1989) 3 SCC 56 Defined assignment as transfer of all rights in property, real or personal
Byramjee Jeejeebhoy (P) Ltd v. State of Maharashtra Supreme Court AIR 1965 SC 590 Clarified nature of lease and transfer of rights, distinguishing lease from sale

Between Fine Lines

For industry, this ruling removes uncertainty over whether GST applies when industrial plots allotted by GIDC are assigned. The Court has clarified that once a lessee transfers leasehold rights absolutely to another party, it is treated as transfer of immovable property. This means no GST liability arises on such assignments, though stamp duty implications remain. Businesses can now avoid wrongful GST demands on assignments of leasehold plots.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY