Case Summary
W.P.(C) 6758/2024 – M/s Ace Cardiopathy Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
High Court of Delhi | Petition under Article 226 read with Section 73 CGST Act
Judgment dated: 10.05.2024
Category: Adjudication under Section 73 – Validity of Service of SCN
Facts (Paras 1–3, 8–9)
The petitioner challenged an order dated 13.03.2024 passed under Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017, whereby tax, interest and penalty were levied on the allegation that the petitioner failed to respond to the Show Cause Notice (SCN) dated 08.12.2023. The petitioner asserted that the SCN was never visible in the normal workflow of the GST portal. Instead of appearing under the usual “View Notices and Orders” tab, the SCN had been uploaded by the Department under “Additional Notices and Orders”, a location that is neither intuitively accessible nor routinely checked by taxpayers. As a result, the petitioner remained unaware of the SCN and consequently did not file a reply or appear for personal hearing. The impugned order itself records non-submission of reply, thereby confirming that adjudication proceeded ex parte. The petitioner therefore sought quashing of the order and a direction for fresh adjudication after granting proper notice and hearing.
Questions for Consideration (Paras 2, 4–7)
-
Whether uploading of an SCN under “Additional Notices and Orders” instead of the standard “View Notices” tab satisfies the requirement of valid service under Section 169 of the CGST Act?
-
Whether adjudication under Section 73 can sustain where the taxpayer is deprived of an effective opportunity to contest the allegations due to portal architecture inconsistencies?
-
Whether natural justice mandates reopening of adjudication when a taxpayer demonstrates that non-appearance occurred due to non-visibility of the SCN?
Court’s Observations (Paras 4–8)
The Court examined the Revenue’s argument that uploading the notice on the portal constitutes deemed service under Section 169(1)(d) CGST Act. However, the Court found the contention untenable because the manner of uploading critically impacts actual accessibility. The Court relied on multiple judgments of the Madras High Court—East Coast Constructions (11.09.2023), connected batch in W.P. 22369/2023 (31.07.2023), and Murugesan Jayalakshmi (08.02.2024)—which documented systemic GSTN issues involving parallel tabs:
-
“View Notices and Orders” and
-
“View Additional Notices and Orders”
These rulings recognised that placement of notices under the latter tab often results in the taxpayer unknowingly missing critical communications because that tab was located under User Services, not under the main statutory notices dashboard.
The Court noted (Para 8) that the petitioner had made out a credible case of having missed the SCN due to non-standard placement on the GST portal, compounded by the portal architecture that had already been criticised in earlier judicial pronouncements. As the impugned order itself recorded non-appearance, the Court held that an opportunity of reply and hearing must be restored.
Judgment / Verdict (Paras 9–11)
The Court held that the ex parte adjudication under Section 73 suffered from procedural irregularity, as the SCN had not been effectively served in a manner that provided real notice. Invoking principles of natural justice, the Court:
-
Set aside the impugned order dated 13.03.2024.
-
Directed the Department to re-open the GST portal to allow furnishing of reply to the SCN dated 08.12.2023 within 30 days.
-
Mandated that a fresh adjudication be completed within four weeks thereafter.
-
Required that the petitioner be afforded a personal hearing.
Thus, the demand stood quashed and the matter was remanded for de novo adjudication.
Summary of Cases Referred (Tabular Form)
| Case | Court | Issue Considered | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| East Coast Constructions & Industries Ltd. v. AC (ST) (11.09.2023) | Madras HC | SCNs uploaded under “Additional Notices” rather than main notices tab | Held that such placement causes prejudice; Department directed to address the portal design defect |
| Batch led by W.P. 22369/2023 (31.07.2023) | Madras HC | Taxpayer failed to notice SCN due to complex portal architecture | Court held orders vitiated as non-service was attributable to portal layout; remedial directions issued |
| Murugesan Jayalakshmi v. STO (08.02.2024) | Madras HC | Review of portal redesign and validity of service | Court noted GSTN has merged tabs; reinstated matters where SCN was missed due to earlier architecture |
Between Fine Lines – Practical Takeaways for Trade & Industry
Taxpayers must regularly review both “View Notices” and “Additional Notices” tabs, as historic GSTN design placed communications unpredictably. However, when an SCN is missed due to portal architecture, adjudication orders passed without participation can be successfully challenged. Courts insist that service must be not merely technical but effective, and natural justice prevails over mechanical reliance on Section 169.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”



