Association of Diplomate of National Board Doctors & Anr. v. National Medical Commission & Ors., Delhi High Court, W.P.(C) 10326/2021
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 10326/2021 & CM APPL. 31787/2021
Date of Judgment: 01 November 2023
Category of Dispute: GST applicability — Exemption — Education services
Relevant GST Law:
-
Section 9, CGST Act, 2017 (levy)
-
Entry 66 of Notification No. 12/2017-CT(R) — exemption to educational services
-
General principles of unjust enrichment under CGST Act
Primary Issue: Whether NBE was legally entitled to collect 18% GST on annual course fee payable by DNB/DrNB/FNB trainees.
Facts of the Case
(Paras 1–9 of extracted order)
The petitioners, representing DNB/DrNB/FNB medical trainees, challenged three notifications dated 15.01.2021, 15.02.2021, and 19.08.2021 issued by the National Board of Examinations (NBE). These notifications mandated GST @18% on the annual course fee of ₹1,25,000, resulting in a total demand of ₹1,47,500 from each trainee. The petitioners argued that such training services were exempt under the GST framework and that the levy on course fees was patently illegal.
During proceedings, the Union of India and GST authorities confirmed that GST was indeed not chargeable on such course fees. NBE also conceded that the levy was an error. However, NBE disclosed that although a small portion of the collected GST remained with it, the majority had already been transferred to the respective accredited hospitals.
In view of this admitted mistake and the wide-scale financial impact, the Court had earlier directed NBE to file a detailed affidavit (Order dated 19.05.2023) disclosing candidate-wise collection and hospital-wise remittances.
Questions for Determination
(Implied across Paras 1–10)
-
Whether GST was legally leviable on the DNB course fee collected by NBE.
-
Whether the impugned notifications mandating collection of GST required judicial invalidation.
-
What directions must be issued to ensure return of GST illegally collected and partly transferred to hospitals.
Court’s Observations
(Paras 5–12)
The Court recorded the explicit admissions of the GST authorities and NBE that GST was never payable on the course fee charged to DNB trainees. The Court noted that NBE had wrongly collected the amount and had further transmitted a substantial portion of GST along with the course fee to hospitals.
The Court found merit in the petitioners’ contention that the impugned notifications, to the extent they mandated GST collection, could not stand in law. It accepted NBE’s statement that a public notice withdrawing the impugned notifications would be issued.
Given the large number of candidates and the fact that the amounts were disbursed across hospitals, the Court deemed it essential to prescribe structured, time-bound directions to ensure complete restitution. It also noted that two to three transactions remained untraceable and required further effort from NBE.
Final Judgment
(Paras 6–15)
The Delhi High Court held the GST levy to be illegal and quashed the impugned notifications to the extent they mandated GST on course fees. Key operative directions include:
-
NBE is restrained from collecting GST on course fees henceforth.
-
NBE must refund GST wherever the amount is still with it.
-
Hospitals must refund GST if they received GST along with course fee but have not deposited it with GST authorities.
-
Where GST has already been deposited by hospitals, they must apply for refund from the GST Department and, once received, refund the trainees.
-
GST authorities are requested to process refund applications expeditiously.
-
NBE must trace the remaining unlinked transactions and ensure restitution.
-
NBE must communicate the order to all hospitals for strict compliance.
The writ petition was disposed with liberty to apply for further directions if required.
Summary of Cases Referred (Table Form)
Note: The uploaded judgment does not cite any external case-law. Accordingly, no referenced precedents exist.
| Case Name | Court | Issue | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| None cited in judgment | — | — | — |
“Between Fine Lines” – Practical Takeaways for Trade & Education Sector
The ruling reinforces that educational services that fall within the GST exemption framework cannot be subjected to inadvertent or administrative taxation, even by statutory bodies like NBE. Once an authority admits tax was wrongly collected, it carries a strict obligation to trace, recover, and restitute the full amount. Entities handling student-related funds must ensure rigorous GST classification reviews because wrongful levy causes cascading disputes across candidates, institutions, and tax authorities. Hospitals receiving course fees cannot retain GST amounts, irrespective of internal arrangements with NBE.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




