Case Title: Paresh Nathalal Chauhan v. State of Gujarat
Court Name: High Court of Gujarat
Petition Number: Special Civil Application No. 18463 of 2019
Date of Judgment: 24 December 2019
Category of Dispute: Search and Seizure under GST
Relevant Sections: Section 67(2), 70, 144, 157 of CGST Act, 2017; Section 132 of the Income Tax Act; IPC Sections 348; CrPC Sections 93, 94, 100, 165
Issue: Violation of procedural and constitutional safeguards during search operation under GST law
Facts of the Case [¶1–16.11]
The petitioner’s residential premises were searched by GST authorities under Section 67(2) of the CGST Act from 11.10.2019 to 18.10.2019. The officers camped inside the house, interrogated family members including women and a minor girl, seized mobile data, and restricted the family’s movement. Despite the search concluding on the first day, officers stayed continuously for eight days, justifying it by claiming ongoing investigation based on call recordings. No female officers were present during night shifts, and no proper authorisation existed for continued presence.
Questions in Consideration [¶18–21]
- Whether continued stay of officers at the petitioner’s residence after completion of search on 11.10.2019 was legal?
- Whether officers were authorised to interrogate family members and restrict their movements under Section 67(2) of the CGST Act?
- Whether seizure of mobile phones and extraction of data from non-notified persons (i.e., family members) was legally justified?
- Whether the procedural powers under CrPC and GST were abused and fundamental rights violated?
Observations of the Court [¶15–28]
- Scope of Section 67(2) CGST Act: Authorises search of premises for goods, documents, books or things; it does not extend to prolonged stay, interrogation or coercion of family members. [¶15–18]
- Violation of Fundamental Rights: The conduct amounted to wrongful confinement, invasion of privacy (Art. 21), and possibly an offence under IPC Section 348. [¶20–21]
- No Authority for Coercive Measures: The officers’ reliance on past VAT practice under GVAT Act does not confer legality under the CGST regime. Recording statements without summons under Section 70 was illegal. [¶22–25]
- Criticism of Authorities: The court strongly deprecated the Chief Commissioner’s report for justifying illegal conduct rather than reprimanding the errant officers. [¶24–27]
- Legal Protection and Good Faith: The court cautioned that protection under Section 157(2) CGST Act will not apply to actions lacking statutory backing or violating fundamental rights. [¶28]
Judgment of the Court [¶29–31]
The High Court held that the actions of the GST officers, particularly the prolonged stay and coercive conduct at the petitioner’s residence, were without authority of law and violated the fundamental rights of the family members. The court directed that such practices must not be repeated and emphasised accountability of officers acting beyond their lawful powers.
Between Fine Lines:
- Search under GST law is limited to documents, goods, and things—not to persons.
- Officers cannot camp at residential premises or interrogate uninvolved family members.
- Statements must be recorded only through proper summons under Section 70.
- Presence of male officers round-the-clock in a household with women and minors without legal sanction breaches privacy rights.
- Even search proceedings must strictly follow due process to avoid constitutional violations.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| District Registrar and Collector v. Canara Bank | [2005] 1 SCC 496 | Privacy must be protected even during search; any search is a serious invasion and must be strictly backed by law. | Upheld privacy under Article 21; restrictions require compelling state interest. |
| M.P. Sharma v. Satish Chandra | AIR 1954 SC 300 | Earlier ruling on search and seizure in context of Article 19 & 20. | Held search is not necessarily a violation of Article 20(3). |
| Kharak Singh v. State of UP | AIR 1963 SC 1295 | Surveillance violates Article 21; privacy protected. | Majority invalidated domiciliary visits; minority upheld privacy as fundamental right. |
| Gobind v. State of MP | AIR 1975 SC 1378 | Developed the concept of right to privacy. | Right to privacy is implied under Article 21 and subject to reasonable restrictions. |
| R. Rajagopal v. State of TN | (1994) 6 SCC 632 | Reaffirmed the right to privacy. | Upheld the right to be let alone. |
| ITO v. Seth Brothers | [1969] 74 ITR 836 (SC) | Powers of search are invasive and must be used strictly for authorised purposes. | Unlawful search cannot be justified by its success. |
| Dr. Nand Lal Tahiliani v. CIT | [1988] 170 ITR 592 (All HC) | Dwelling house is a high fortress; search must not intrude unlawfully. | Unlawful searches breach constitutional rights. |




