Home Case Laws GST Order Quashed Due to Non-Consideration of Reply and Violation of Natural...

GST Order Quashed Due to Non-Consideration of Reply and Violation of Natural Justice

0
574

Case Title: Younobi Technologies Pvt. Ltd. vs Union of India
Court: High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad
Petition No.: WP (C) No. 20611 of 2024
Category: Natural Justice / Adjudication Procedure
Date of Judgement: 30.09.2024
Relevant Section: Section 75(4) of the CGST Act, 2017
CGST Rules Referred: Rule 142 – issuance of SCN and reply under ASMT-10 and Form DRC-01A


Facts of the Case (¶1–2)

  • The petitioner, Younobi Technologies Pvt. Ltd., challenged the adjudication order dated 25.04.2024 passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax (Ranga Reddy CGST Commissionerate).

  • A show cause notice (SCN) was issued on 27.12.2023. The petitioner duly submitted a reply on 16.04.2024.

  • As per GST portal status (pg. 36), the reply was acknowledged as “Reply furnished, pending for order by tax officer.”

  • However, the impugned order erroneously stated that no reply was filed by the petitioner, violating Section 75(4) of CGST Act.

Questions in Consideration (¶2–3)

  • Whether the impugned adjudication order violated the principles of natural justice by failing to consider the petitioner’s reply?

  • Whether the proceedings were conducted in accordance with Section 75(4) of the CGST Act and the requirement of SCN response under Rule 142?

Observations of the Court (¶4–5)

  • The court noted that the department failed to rebut the documentary evidence showing the reply was indeed submitted.

  • The portal clearly reflected the reply status, making the adjudicating authority’s contrary claim unsustainable.

  • The court held that denying the petitioner an opportunity of proper hearing and not considering the reply amounts to gross violation of natural justice.

Judgement of the Court (¶6)

  • The impugned order dated 25.04.2024 was quashed.

  • The adjudicating authority was directed to consider the reply submitted by the petitioner and proceed further in accordance with law from that stage.

  • The writ petition was disposed of without any cost.


Between Fine Lines:

  • GST orders must acknowledge replies if submitted, even if not manually reiterated during hearings.

  • Digital records like GST portal status can override adjudicator’s claims.

  • Ignoring replies submitted violates Section 75(4) and natural justice.

  • Pre-consultation and due opportunity are mandatory under Rule 142 and Form DRC-01A.

  • A taxpayer’s defence cannot be brushed aside due to procedural lapse by authority.


Summary of Referred Cases:

Name Citation Summary Verdict
None specifically cited in judgment – – –

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY