Case: Shyama Power India Ltd. v. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors., High Court of Himachal Pradesh, CWP No. 6990 of 2025, decided on 19.06.2025
Relevant Section: Section 74 & Section 161 of HP GST Act, 2017; Rule 101(4) of HP GST Rules, 2017
Category: Input Tax Credit (ITC) dispute
Facts (Paras 3–13)
Shyama Power India Ltd., engaged in construction of transmission lines and registered under the HP GST Act, faced an audit under Section 65 for FY 2017–18 and 2018–19. The audit alleged wrongful availment of ITC worth ₹1.11 crore on purchases from three suppliers. Despite furnishing reconciliations, ledgers, bank statements, purchase orders, and affidavits from transporters, the authorities continued to pressurize the petitioner. To avoid coercive action, the petitioner reversed the ITC under protest through DRC-03 on 31.03.2023. Later, the Commissioner passed an order under Section 74 on 02.12.2023 imposing interest of ₹1.32 crore and penalty of ₹1.11 crore, treating the protest deposit as admitted liability. The petitioner could not appeal against the main tax demand due to GST portal restrictions and sought rectification under Section 161, which was refused, leading to this writ petition.
Questions before the Court
-
Whether deposit of ITC “under protest” can be treated as admission of liability to justify levy of interest and penalty?
-
Whether the adjudicating authority erred in not conducting an independent inquiry before reversing ITC and passing penalty/interest orders?
-
Whether denial of opportunity to appeal against the main demand due to GST portal restrictions violates petitioner’s rights?
Observations (Paras 15–19)
The Court noted with concern the arbitrary manner in which the Commissioner acted. It held that any deposit made “under protest” signifies non-admission of liability, preserving the right to challenge. Reliance was placed on the definition of “under protest” in Black’s Law Dictionary. The Court emphasized that reversal of ITC merely on suspicion, without independent investigation, was impermissible. Treating the protested deposit as voluntary payment and thereafter imposing penalty and interest was held perverse and unjust.
Judgement (Paras 20–21)
The High Court allowed the writ petition. The impugned order dated 02.12.2023 under Section 74 of HP GST Act, imposing interest and penalty, was quashed. The Court directed issuance of a fresh DRC-07 showing only the disputed tax of ₹1.11 crore to enable the petitioner to appeal before the appellate authority. It was clarified that the petitioner is free to raise all grounds, both in this petition and earlier, before the authority.
Table of cases referred
| Case Reference | Verdict / Principle |
|---|---|
| Black’s Law Dictionary, 10th Ed., definition of “under protest” | Payment under protest does not amount to admission of liability; it preserves the right to dispute. |
Between Fine Lines
For industry, this ruling clarifies that any GST deposit made “under protest” cannot be treated as voluntary admission of liability. Authorities must conduct independent investigation before disallowing ITC and imposing penalty/interest. Taxpayers should explicitly mark reversals as “under protest” to safeguard their appellate rights.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




