Case Reference
SL Yadav Cranes Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. & Another
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Writ Tax No. 607 of 2025
Order dated: 07.03.2025
Coram: Arun Bhansali, CJ. & Kshitij Shailendra, J.
Relevant Section: Section 129 of the CGST Act, 2017
Category: Detention of goods / Penalty under E-Way Bill dispute
Neutral Citation: 2025:AHC:34268-DB
Facts (Para 1–4)
The petitioner, a company engaged in providing machinery on rent, was hired by L&T Ltd. for one day at its Ghaziabad project site. Machinery was transported on 14.01.2025 with an e-way bill and delivery challan. After completion, while returning to Delhi on 15.01.2025, the vehicle was intercepted. Though documents were produced, the officer recorded in GST MOV-01 and MOV-02 that no documents were shown. Verification in MOV-04 confirmed no discrepancy in goods. However, detention under Section 129(1) was made solely because the vehicle number in the e-way bill was wrongly typed as HR-46C-4623 instead of HR-58C-4623. Despite reply explaining the typographical error and ownership proof, proceedings were concluded against the driver and a penalty of ₹59,00,000 was imposed under Section 129(3).
Questions / Dispute (Para 3–6)
The dispute centered on whether a mere typographical error in vehicle number in the e-way bill can justify detention of goods and imposition of penalty under Section 129(1)(b).
Observations (Para 8–11)
The Court noted that documents (invoice and e-way bill) did accompany the goods, with discrepancy only in the vehicle number. Ownership was admitted by the petitioner. Importantly, a coordinate bench in M/s Halder Enterprises v. State of U.P. (Writ Tax No. 1297 of 2023, decided 11.12.2023) had already held that where tax invoice and e-way bill are produced and ownership claimed, proceedings must fall under Section 129(1)(a), not Section 129(1)(b). Circular dated 31.12.2018 also supported this interpretation. Hence, penalty under Section 129(1)(b) was unjustified.
Judgment / Verdict (Para 12–14)
The Court quashed the impugned penalty order dated 22.01.2025 and directed the authorities to apply Section 129(1)(a) for release of goods. The petitioner remains free to pursue other remedies as per law.
Table of Referred Case
| Case | Citation | Principle / Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| M/s Halder Enterprises v. State of U.P. & Ors. | Writ Tax No. 1297 of 2023 (Allahabad HC, decided 11.12.2023) | Held that when e-way bill and invoice are produced and ownership claimed, detention must be dealt with under Section 129(1)(a) (owner’s security) and not under Section 129(1)(b). |
Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)
Minor clerical errors such as a typographical mistake in vehicle number on e-way bills cannot invite harsh penalties under GST. Once ownership is claimed and documents substantiate the transaction, detention should be resolved under Section 129(1)(a) by furnishing security, not by treating goods as without valid documents under 129(1)(b). This safeguards genuine businesses from disproportionate penalties.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




