Case Title: Nishad K.U. v. Joint Commissioner, Central Tax & CE & Ors.
Court: High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 26732 of 2024
Date of Judgement: 17 December 2024
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit / Penalty – Violation of Natural Justice
Relevant Sections: Section 74(9), 107, 122(1), 75(4) of CGST/SGST Act, Article 226 Constitution of India
Facts of the Case (Para 1–4, 10, 17)
-
The petitioner, proprietor of M/s Woodtunes Enterprises, faced penalties exceeding ₹18.80 crores under Section 74(9) of CGST Act and Section 122(1) of SGST Act for alleged fake registrations and wrongful ITC (Para 1–2).
-
Show Cause Notice alleged misuse of Aadhaar/PAN of “goalies” to generate fake invoices and circular trading (Para 4).
-
Petitioner denied charges, filed reply dated 16.01.2024, and specifically sought cross-examination of 20 witnesses, alleging coercion in recording statements (Para 3).
-
Request for cross-examination was rejected on 07.02.2024, despite affidavits of retraction being filed (Para 3, 10).
-
Final order dated 29.05.2024 imposed huge penalties without granting cross-examination (Para 10, 17).
Question(s) in Consideration (Para 6–8)
-
Whether the writ petition is maintainable despite alternate remedy under Section 107 CGST Act (Para 6–7).
-
Whether denial of cross-examination of witnesses, whose statements formed the basis of penalty, amounted to violation of natural justice (Para 8–9).
Observations of Court (Para 7–18)
-
On maintainability: Since appellate authority under Section 107(11) cannot remand cases for violation of natural justice, writ jurisdiction under Article 226 was held maintainable (Para 7).
-
On cross-examination: Court held that though Section 75(4) CGST Act provides only “opportunity of hearing,” fairness requires cross-examination if statements of third parties are relied upon (Para 8–9).
-
The adjudicating authority wrongly assumed cross-examination would not affect credibility of statements; such presumption was impermissible (Para 12).
-
Relied on precedents:
-
Andaman Timber Industries v. CCE (2016) – denial of cross-examination makes order nullity (Para 13).
-
K.T. Shaduli Yusuff (1977) – tax proceedings bound by natural justice, cross-examination integral (Para 14).
-
Roshan Sharma v. ACST, West Bengal (2024) – refusal of cross-examination leads to remand (Para 15).
-
Mohammed Fariz & Co. v. Commissioner of Customs (2019) – early cross-examination aids proper adjudication (Para 16).
-
-
Court held reliance on unilateral statements without permitting cross-examination violated principles of natural justice (Para 18).
Judgement of the Court (Para 20)
-
The impugned penalty order dated 29.05.2024 was set aside.
-
Matter remanded to the adjudicating authority to decide afresh after granting opportunity for cross-examination of witnesses.
-
Directed to complete proceedings within six months (Para 20).
Between Fine Lines (Simplified Outcome in 5 Lines)
The Kerala High Court quashed a GST penalty of ₹18.80 crores for violation of natural justice.
Since statements of 20 witnesses were relied upon, denial of cross-examination was fatal.
The Court held that appellate remedy was inadequate due to lack of remand power.
Cited multiple precedents emphasising that fairness requires cross-examination when sought.
Matter remanded for fresh adjudication with mandatory cross-examination.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Andaman Timber Industries v. CCE | (2016) 15 SCC 785 | Denial of cross-examination makes adjudication order nullity. | SC set aside penalty. |
| State of Kerala v. K.T. Shaduli Yusuff | (1977) 2 SCC 777 | Sales tax proceedings require adherence to natural justice; cross-examination vital. | SC upheld cross-examination right. |
| Roshan Sharma v. ACST, West Bengal | M.A.T. No.854 of 2024 (Calcutta HC) | Refusal to cross-examine witnesses in GST matter is violation of natural justice. | Case remanded. |
| Mohammed Fariz & Co. v. Commissioner of Customs | 2019 (1) KLT 229 | Cross-examination strengthens adjudication and protects fairness. | HC allowed cross-examination. |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




