Case Details
Case Title: M/s Agarwal Steels v. Additional Commissioner Grade-2 and Another
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 884 of 2024
Neutral Citation: 2025:AHC:22221
Date of Judgment: 17.02.2025
Category of Dispute: Penalty under Section 129 – E-invoice not accompanying goods
Relevant Sections: Section 129 of CGST Act, 2017; Rule 138A of CGST Rules, 2017
Facts of the Case (Para refs: pp.2–4 of order)
M/s Agarwal Steels purchased iron scrap through e-auction from Northern Railway in February 2024, paying applicable GST and TDS. On 4.03.2024, the firm sold part of the scrap to a Punjab buyer, raising a valid tax invoice and generating e-way bill. The goods were transported through Truck No. UP 20 AT-9997. At Devband, Saharanpur, the mobile squad intercepted the vehicle. Though the invoice, e-way bill, and bilty matched the consignment with no quantity or description discrepancy, the goods were detained solely because the e-invoice was not available on hand. Proceedings under Section 129 were initiated, penalty imposed on 6.03.2024, and appeal dismissed on 3.04.2024.
Questions of Law (Para refs: pp.5–7)
-
Whether penalty under Section 129 can be sustained when all essential documents (invoice, e-way bill, bilty) were present but e-invoice could not be generated due to GST portal glitches?
-
Whether absence of e-invoice alone, without finding of intent to evade tax, justifies seizure and penalty?
-
Whether curing the deficiency before passing the detention order bars penalty under GST jurisprudence?
Observations of the Court (Para refs: pp.8–10)
The Court noted that:
-
All transport documents were present and undisputed.
-
Authorities did not record any finding of tax evasion or intent to evade.
-
The petitioner explained that the e-invoice could not be generated due to portal glitches, a fact not denied by the State.
-
Reliance was placed on Shyam Sel & Power Ltd. v. State of U.P. (2023) and Galaxy Enterprises v. State of U.P. (2023), where it was held that if deficiencies are cured before the detention order, no penalty is justified.
Judgment (Para refs: pp.11–13)
The High Court held that mere absence of e-invoice at the time of interception, when cured before detention order and without any intent to evade tax, cannot justify penalty under Section 129. Both orders dated 6.03.2024 and 3.04.2024 were quashed. The writ petition was allowed, and the State was directed to refund the penalty amount within two months.
Case Law Table
| Case Referred | Citation | Ratio Decidendi |
|---|---|---|
| Shyam Sel & Power Ltd. v. State of U.P. | (2023) 11 Centax 99 (All.) | No penalty if deficiency in documents is rectified before detention order; absence of intent to evade tax is crucial. |
| Galaxy Enterprises v. State of U.P. | (2023) 12 Centax 137 (All.) | Penalty under Section 129 not justified where procedural lapses are technical and corrected promptly. |
Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)
For trade and industry, this judgment confirms that penalties under Section 129 cannot be imposed for mere technical lapses such as delayed e-invoice generation when all other documents are in place and tax payment is not disputed. Businesses should promptly cure deficiencies and produce documents before detention orders, as courts will safeguard against undue penalties in absence of evasion intent.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




