Home Case Laws GST penalty quashed as no discrepancy found in invoices or quantity and...

GST penalty quashed as no discrepancy found in invoices or quantity and no intent to evade tax could be established

0
204

Case Details

Case Title: Ashok Sharma v. State of West Bengal & Ors.
Court: Calcutta High Court (Division Bench – Chief Justice T.S. Sivagnanam & Justice Hiranmay Bhattacharyya)
Petition No.: FMA 136 of 2025 with CAN/1/2024
Judgment Date: 11 February 2025
Category of Dispute: Detention of goods & levy of penalty – Section 129 of CGST Act
Relevant Sections: Section 129 of the CGST Act, 2017

Facts (Para 1–2)

The appellant challenged a series of actions by the GST authorities: the show-cause notice dated 27 June 2024, an unsigned summary notice dated 5 July 2024, and an order demanding tax and penalty through Form MOV-09 dated 15 July 2024, affirmed by the appellate authority on 4 October 2024. The dispute arose when goods transported under three invoices were detained during inspection. The department alleged discrepancies between the invoices and the goods carried, indicating intent to evade tax. The Single Judge dismissed the writ petition, upholding the authority’s action, leading to this appeal.


Questions of Law (Para 2)

  1. Whether there was any variance between goods covered by invoices and those physically found.

  2. Whether intent to evade tax could be inferred when description was broadly matching and classification was not disputed.

  3. Whether detention under Section 129 CGST Act was justified in such facts.


Observations (Para 3)

The Division Bench observed that:

  • The invoices broadly described the goods (pipes, shutter materials, TMT bars) with correct weight and quantity.

  • Physical verification revealed no discrepancy in quantity or classification; HSN codes were consistent.

  • The inspecting officer went beyond invoices to record unnecessary details like size specifications not required under law.

  • No evidence suggested intent to evade tax; hence, Section 129 could not be invoked.


Judgement (Para 3–4)

The Court held that the detention and penalty were unjustified. Orders of the original authority and appellate authority were quashed. The appeal was allowed, the writ petition restored, and authorities directed to release the vehicle and goods within four days. The appellant was given liberty to claim refund of pre-deposit made during the appeal process.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Verdict / Ratio
No external precedents were referred explicitly in this judgment N/A

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this ruling emphasizes that GST authorities cannot detain goods under Section 129 merely on vague assumptions or by introducing extra details beyond invoices. If quantity, weight, and classification match the invoices and HSN, detention and penalty lack legal sanctity. Traders can contest such actions, and pre-deposits made during appeals may be refunded.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY