Case Details
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Case No.: Writ Tax No. 1534 of 2024
Petitioner: M/s Saru Silver Alloys Pvt Ltd
Respondents: Union of India & Others
Date of Order: 06.12.2024
Relevant Provisions: Rule 96(10) of CGST Rules, 2017; Rule 86(4B)(b) of CGST Rules, 2017
Category of Dispute: Refund – Export related restrictions under Rule 96(10)
Facts (Para 1–2)
The petitioner challenged the order in original dated 16.04.2024 (rectified on 12.06.2024), where refund benefits were denied based on Rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules, 2017. The petitioner argued that this very provision was struck down by the Kerala High Court in M/s Sance Laboratories Pvt Ltd v. Union of India (2024 SCC OnLine Ker 6334). They further submitted that reliance on the Gujarat High Court decision in Cosmo Films Ltd v. Union of India (2020 (43) GSTL 577) was misplaced, as the said judgment was reviewed on 19.09.2024.
The petitioner also highlighted that the Central Government, by Notification dated 08.10.2024, prospectively amended Rule 86(4B)(b) to omit the phrase “in contravention of sub-rule (10) of Rule 96”, thereby weakening the basis of the impugned order.
Questions before the Court (Para 1–2)
-
Whether the denial of refund and subsequent recovery based on Rule 96(10) was sustainable, when the provision itself stood struck down by another High Court.
-
Whether reliance on Cosmo Films Ltd. was valid in light of its review in September 2024.
-
Whether the prospective omission of the reference to Rule 96(10) from Rule 86(4B)(b) by the Government impacts the legality of earlier orders.
Court’s Observations (Para 3–4)
The Court took note of the submissions regarding the Kerala High Court decision striking down Rule 96(10), the review of the Gujarat High Court judgment, and the Central Government’s subsequent amendment. Recognizing that these raised substantial legal questions, the Court issued notice and granted time for counter and rejoinder affidavits.
Judgment / Interim Order (Para 5)
The Court directed that, in the meantime and until further orders, the recovery pursuant to the order in original dated 16.04.2024 (as rectified on 12.06.2024) shall remain stayed.
Case Law References and Outcomes
| Case | Court | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| M/s Sance Laboratories Pvt Ltd v. Union of India (2024 SCC OnLine Ker 6334) | Kerala HC | Struck down Rule 96(10) of CGST Rules as unconstitutional. |
| Cosmo Films Ltd v. Union of India (2020 (43) GSTL 577) | Gujarat HC | Initially upheld restrictions under Rule 96(10); later reviewed on 19.09.2024. |
Between Fine Lines
This order signals that recovery actions based on Rule 96(10) are on shaky ground. With one High Court striking it down, another reviewing its earlier support, and the Government itself omitting its reference in Rule 86(4B)(b), businesses facing refund denials under this rule have strong grounds for relief. Exporters should closely monitor the final outcome as it could reset the framework for claiming GST refunds against export obligations.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




