Home Case Laws GST recovery stayed as Tribunal yet to be constituted and taxpayer fulfilled...

GST recovery stayed as Tribunal yet to be constituted and taxpayer fulfilled pre-deposit and undertaking requirements

0
277

Case Title: Sagar Industries & Anr. v. Assistant Commissioner of Revenue & Ors.
Court: Calcutta High Court
Petition No.: WPA 29507 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 05 February 2025
Category: Recovery Stay – Appellate Tribunal Non-Constitution
Relevant Sections: Sections 107(6) and 112(8) & (9) of the CGST Act, 2017; Circular No. 224/18/2024-GST dated 11 July 202

Facts (Paras 1–3):

The petitioners, Sagar Industries & Anr., challenged an appellate order dated 31 May 2024 before the Calcutta High Court. They contended that recovery of dues under the impugned order should be stayed since the GST Appellate Tribunal had not yet been constituted. The petitioners relied on Circular No. 224/18/2024-GST (11 July 2024), which directed that in cases where the first appeal is disposed of and the taxpayer intends to appeal before the Tribunal, recovery proceedings must be deferred upon payment of the prescribed pre-deposit and furnishing of an undertaking.


Questions before the Court (Para 3):

Whether recovery of confirmed tax demand could lawfully proceed when the taxpayer has already deposited the pre-deposit under Section 107(6) and intends to file a further appeal before the Tribunal, which is not yet functional.


Observations (Paras 4–6):

The Court observed that the Finance Ministry’s circular provides a clear procedural safeguard under Sections 112(8) and 112(9): once the taxpayer pays an additional 10% of the disputed tax and submits an undertaking to file a Tribunal appeal upon its constitution, recovery must remain stayed. The circular aims to prevent hardship arising from the Tribunal’s delay in constitution. The Court accepted that the petitioners had established a prima facie case warranting interim protection.


Judgment (Paras 6–8):

Justice Rajarshi Bharadwaj granted an unconditional stay of recovery for two weeks. The Court further directed that if the petitioners pay 10% of the balance disputed tax, in addition to the 10% already deposited under Section 107(6), the interim stay shall continue until disposal of the writ petition or further orders, whichever occurs earlier. The State was directed to file its affidavit-in-opposition within six weeks, with a one-week period thereafter for reply.


Summary of Referred Provisions and Circular

Reference Subject Relevance
Section 107(6) Pre-deposit of 10% of tax for first appeal Already complied with by petitioner
Section 112(8) Additional 20% pre-deposit for appeal before Tribunal Tribunal not yet operational
Section 112(9) Automatic stay on recovery upon pre-deposit Relief extended through circular
Circular No. 224/18/2024-GST Clarifies recovery deferment till Tribunal setup Adopted by Court in interim order

Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway):

This decision reinforces that no recovery can be initiated when the taxpayer expresses intent to appeal before the GST Tribunal, provided the mandatory pre-deposit and undertaking are made. The ruling safeguards taxpayers from coercive recovery in the transitional phase before the Tribunal’s establishment and aligns administrative practice with the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs’ circular instructions.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY