Home Case Laws GST Registration cancelled without considering the reply of assessee is not maintainable.

GST Registration cancelled without considering the reply of assessee is not maintainable.

0
508

Case Title: Ashwani Agarwal v. Union of India

Court: High Court of Allahabad

Petition Number: Writ Tax No. 451 of 2020

Category of Dispute: GST Registration Cancellation

Date of Judgement: 7 September 2020

Relevant Section: Section 30 of the CGST Act, 2017

 

Facts of the Case [¶2–6]

  1. The petitioner, Ashwani Agarwal, registered under GST (GSTIN: 09AAPPA8995F1Z4), was issued a notice on 24-04-2019 by the GST Department regarding certain discrepancies, to which he replied via speed post on 03-05-2019 and submitted purchase details on 15-05-2019. [¶5]
  2. A subsequent show cause notice for cancellation of registration was issued on 14-02-2020. Petitioner’s counsel appeared on 25-02-2020 expecting further details. [¶5]
  3. Despite this, an order cancelling the registration was passed on 14-04-2020 citing non-appearance and non-submission of reply. However, the order itself referenced the reply dated 25-02-2020, creating an internal contradiction. [¶5–6]

 

Questions in Consideration [¶3–4]

  1. Whether the writ petition is maintainable in view of the alternative remedy available under Section 30 of the CGST Act for revocation of cancellation? [¶3–4]
  2. Whether the cancellation order dated 14-04-2020 is legally sustainable, being internally contradictory and passed without due application of mind? [¶4]

 

Observations of the Court [¶7–8]

  1. The Court noted that while the cancellation order cites lack of reply as a ground, the same order paradoxically refers to a specific reply dated 25-02-2020 from the petitioner. [¶8]
  2. The learned counsel for the Revenue (Respondents 2 and 3) fairly conceded that the cancellation order was unsustainable and should be remanded for fresh adjudication. [¶7]

 

Judgement of the Court [¶9–10]

  1. The Court set aside the cancellation order dated 14-04-2020 passed by the Superintendent, Kanpur Sector 12, CGST. [¶9]
  2. Liberty was granted to the department to pass a fresh order in accordance with law. [¶9]
  3. The writ petition was allowed without any cost. [¶10]

 

Between Fine Lines (Simplified Outcome)

  • The GST registration of the petitioner was cancelled citing no response, though his reply was acknowledged in the order itself.
  • The High Court found the cancellation order contradictory and arbitrary.
  • The Court set aside the cancellation and allowed the GST officer to re-decide.
  • This ensures procedural fairness in cancellation proceedings.
  • The case reinforces that when administrative orders contradict their own records, judicial intervention is warranted.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None referred — No judicial precedents or case laws were cited or relied upon in this matter. —

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY