CASE SUMMARY
Aditi Agencies Through Its Proprietor Mr. Divyanshu Khurana v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi & Ors.
High Court of Delhi | W.P.(C) 946/2024 | Judgment dated 14.02.2024
Category: Cancellation of Registration (Section 29)
Relevant Provisions: Section 29(2), CGST Act; procedural requirements for SCN and cancellation order.
FACTS OF THE CASE (Paras 1–6)
The petitioner, engaged in the wholesale trading of medicines and duly registered under GST, challenged (i) the show-cause notice dated 09.01.2021, (ii) the cancellation order dated 27.01.2021, and (iii) the appellate order dated 28.04.2023, all emanating from proceedings initiated on the allegation that the petitioner had not filed returns for six months. The show-cause notice did not disclose material particulars or reasons apart from reproducing a generic ground.
The cancellation order, passed on 27.01.2021, purported to cancel the registration retrospectively from 20.12.2020, citing “response not received”, though strangely also referring to the petitioner’s reply dated 19.01.2021, creating a self-contradictory document. Even the demand table showed nil dues, further casting doubt on whether any genuine grounds existed for cancellation. The petitioner submitted that serious illness prevented filing of returns during the relevant period.
The appellate authority dismissed the appeal solely on limitation, without examining the legality of the foundational proceedings.
QUESTIONS FOR DETERMINATION
-
Whether the show-cause notice and cancellation order complied with the mandatory statutory requirement of providing clear reasons and intelligible grounds for cancellation.
-
Whether retrospective cancellation under Section 29(2) was legally sustainable in absence of an objectively recorded satisfaction and without putting the taxpayer to notice.
-
Whether the appellate authority was justified in dismissing the appeal on limitation, despite the foundational illegality of the proceedings.
OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT (Paras 7–10)
The Court found that both the show-cause notice and the cancellation order were vitiated for lack of reasons and clarity. The notice did not inform the petitioner that retrospective cancellation was proposed, thereby depriving him of an opportunity to object. The cancellation order suffered from internal contradictions—referring to a reply received yet stating “response not received”—and did not articulate any factual basis justifying cancellation, particularly retrospective cancellation.
The Court reiterated that Section 29(2) requires the proper officer to form an objective satisfaction regarding the necessity of cancellation and that retrospective effect cannot be granted mechanically. It emphasised that even according to the department, retrospective cancellation has adverse cascading effects—including denial of ITC to recipients—which demands a more rigorous approach and demonstrable reasoning.
Merely because returns are not filed for some months does not justify retrospective cancellation extending to periods where the taxpayer was compliant.
JUDGMENT / VERDICT (Paras 11–12)
The Court set aside:
-
The show-cause notice dated 09.01.2021;
-
The cancellation order dated 27.01.2021;
-
The appellate order dated 28.04.2023.
The GST registration was restored, conditional upon the petitioner filing pending returns up to date. The Court clarified that restoration does not bar the department from initiating proceedings for lawful recovery of tax, interest, or penalty, if otherwise due.
SUMMARY OF CASES REFERRED (IF ANY)
(This judgment does not cite external precedents; hence no table of referred cases applies.)
BETWEEN THE FINE LINES – PRACTICAL TAKEAWAYS FOR INDUSTRY
This judgment underscores that cancellation of GST registration—particularly retrospective cancellation—cannot be ordered through mechanical or templated notices. Authorities must provide specific, intelligible reasons, must form and record objective satisfaction, and must place taxpayers on clear notice when retrospective consequences are proposed. Businesses facing perfunctory notices or contradictory cancellation orders now have a strong basis to challenge such actions as procedurally ultra vires.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




