Home Case Laws GST show cause notice for classification of “Nizam Pakku” quashed as abuse...

GST show cause notice for classification of “Nizam Pakku” quashed as abuse of process since classification already settled by Supreme Court and AAAR

0
297

Case Summary

Case Title: Azam Laminators Pvt. Ltd. v. Additional Director
Court: Madras High Court
Case Number: W.P. No. 17090 of 2022 & W.M.P. Nos. 16390 & 16391 of 2022
Judgment Date: 01.08.2025
Category of Dispute: Classification under GST
Relevant Sections: Section 7 of CGST Act; Rule 104 CGST Rules (Advance Ruling); Notification No. 1/2017-CT (Rate); Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST; Tariff Items 0802, 21069030 CTA


Facts (Paras 3.1–3.11)

The petitioner, M/s. Azam Laminators Pvt. Ltd., manufactured scented areca nuts branded “Nizam Pakku.” The product is essentially betel nut mixed with vegetable oils, menthol, sugar/glucose syrup, spices, and perfumes. The dispute concerned classification—whether under Chapter 08 (0802: areca nuts) or Chapter 21 (21069030: supari/betel nut product).

The petitioner relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Crane Betel Nut Powder Works v. CCE (2007) holding that sweetened betel nuts retain their character as betel nuts. Their product had previously been classified under Chapter 0802 by CESTAT, Apex Court, and AAAR (2021), attracting 5% GST (2.5% CGST + 2.5% SGST).

Despite this settled position, DGGI issued a fresh show cause notice dated 17.05.2022, seeking classification under 21069030 (18% GST).


Respondents’ Contentions (Paras 4.1–4.6)

The department argued that post-GST, classification must be examined in light of “supply” rather than manufacture. Relying on Circular 163/19/2021-GST (06.10.2021) and GST Council recommendations, they contended that “scented sweet supari” falls under 21069030 attracting 18% GST. They also submitted that writ jurisdiction should not be invoked against a show cause notice.


Court’s Observations (Paras 6–15)

The Court noted that:

  • In the Central Excise regime, classification under Chapter 0802 was conclusively settled by the Supreme Court.

  • Even post-GST, the AAAR ruling classified “Nizam Pakku” under 08028090 at 5% GST.

  • The department neither challenged AAAR’s order under Section 104 nor filed appeal. Hence, it is binding.

  • Circular 163/2021 referred only to “supari” (betel nut product) and not to sweetened betel nuts like “Nizam Pakku.”

  • There was no amendment to CTA tariff entries post-GST warranting a change in classification.

  • Re-agitating classification without new facts or law amounted to abuse of process, contrary to Union of India v. Vicco Laboratories (2007).


Judgment (Paras 16–18)

The Court held that the impugned SCN was issued without application of mind, ignoring binding precedents of Supreme Court, CESTAT, and AAAR. Since the issue had attained finality, the show cause notice was quashed.

Result: Writ Petition allowed; Show Cause Notice dated 17.05.2022 quashed; no costs.


Cases Referred

Case Court Ratio / Verdict
Crane Betel Nut Powder Works v. CCE, Tirupati (2007, SC) Supreme Court Sweetened betel nuts remain “betel nuts” under Chapter 0802, not a new product.
Azam Laminators Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE (Civil Appeal No. 4915/2006, SC, 2015) Supreme Court Applied Crane Betel ratio, classified “Nizam Pakku” under 0802.
CESTAT Final Order Nos. 40455-40456/2019 CESTAT Held “Nizam Pakku” classifiable under 0802 despite amendments.
AAR TN Ruling, 2020 AAR Held “Nizam Pakku” under 08028090 at 12% GST.
AAAR TN Order, 2021 AAAR Reduced GST to 5% (2.5% CGST + 2.5% SGST).
Union of India v. Vicco Laboratories (2007, SC) Supreme Court Courts can interfere at SCN stage if notice is without jurisdiction or abuse of law.

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this ruling reinforces that once classification is settled by the Supreme Court and AAAR, the department cannot repeatedly issue fresh notices on the same issue without change in law or facts. Trade can rely on settled jurisprudence for tariff certainty under GST.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY