Home Updates GSTAT: Statutory Printing of Manufacturer’s Name Does Not Make Goods Branded

GSTAT: Statutory Printing of Manufacturer’s Name Does Not Make Goods Branded

0
166

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal, Thane Bench, Maharashtra, has delivered an important judgment concerning the scope of GST exemption available to goods supplied in unit containers without a brand name. The decision examines whether the mandatory printing of a manufacturer’s corporate name and address on product packaging, in compliance with food safety and legal metrology laws, amounts to the use of a “brand name” for the purposes of Notification No. 02/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28 June 2017.

The appeals were filed by the Commissioner, CGST and Central Excise, Raigad Commissionerate, against M/s Godrej Tyson Foods Limited. The dispute related to supplies of frozen poultry and ready-to-cook products made during the financial years 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23. The Revenue challenged the appellate order which had set aside a GST demand of ₹2,26,77,883, along with interest and an equivalent penalty under Section 74 of the CGST Act.

GST: Corporate Name Printed for Statutory Compliance

Godrej Tyson Foods Limited had initially supplied goods in unit containers bearing the logos “Godrej Tyson” and “Godrej Real Good” and discharged GST at the applicable rate. From 5 January 2021, the company removed the specific brand logos from the packaging used for institutional supplies. However, it continued to print its corporate name, address and statutory particulars as required under the Food Safety and Standards (Labelling and Display) Regulations, 2020 and the Legal Metrology Act, 2009.

The Revenue contended that retaining the company name on the packaging continued to establish a commercial connection between the goods and the manufacturer. It argued that the products remained branded despite removal of the logos and were therefore ineligible for exemption.

The Tribunal rejected this contention. It held that a manufacturer’s name and address printed under a statutory obligation serve the purposes of product traceability, consumer safety and regulatory control. Such declarations, when made under compulsion of law, cannot be equated with the voluntary use of a brand name intended to indicate a commercial connection in the course of trade.

The Tribunal observed that statutory identification markings do not enhance the commercial value of goods in the manner contemplated by the definition of a brand name. The mandatory declaration of the manufacturer’s corporate details therefore did not render the unit containers branded.

Brand Name on Invoice Does Not Brand the Goods

The Revenue also relied upon the fact that the invoices issued by the respondent contained the company’s brand name and logo. The Tribunal clarified that the condition under the exemption notification applies to the goods and their packaging.

Where the physical goods do not bear a brand name, the mere appearance of the company’s name or logo on the tax invoice cannot convert the goods into branded goods. The Tribunal therefore held that the exemption could not be denied merely because the invoice contained the supplier’s corporate identity.

Institutional Supplies and Pre-Packaged Goods

The Tribunal separately considered the position after 18 July 2022, when the exemption entry was amended to refer to “pre-packaged and labelled” commodities.

The goods were supplied in bulk to an institutional consumer operating quick-service restaurants. Referring to Rule 3 of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, the Tribunal held that packages intended for institutional consumers do not qualify as pre-packaged commodities meant for retail sale.

The Revenue had not produced sufficient material to displace the respondent’s contention that the supplies were made exclusively for institutional consumption. Consequently, the Tribunal held that the supplies remained eligible for exemption even after the amendment concerning pre-packaged and labelled goods.

Advance Rulings Not Binding on the Tribunal

The adjudicating authority had relied upon certain rulings pronounced by Authorities for Advance Ruling. The Tribunal noted that an advance ruling is binding only upon the applicant who sought the ruling and the jurisdictional authorities concerned.

Such rulings are not binding precedents for the GST Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal further observed that the advance rulings relied upon by the Revenue could not override the legal principles laid down by the Supreme Court and the High Courts on statutory declarations and the meaning of a brand name.

Tribunal Upholds Exemption and Dismisses Revenue Appeals

The Tribunal concluded that the discontinuance of brand logos on the packaging, while retaining the manufacturer’s corporate name and address solely for statutory compliance, did not amount to affixing a brand name.

It accordingly held that the goods supplied by Godrej Tyson Foods Limited were eligible for exemption under Notification No. 02/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28 June 2017, as amended. The demand for tax, interest and penalty was therefore unsustainable.

The Order-in-Appeal dated 21 March 2025, which had set aside the original demand, was upheld. All three appeals filed by the Revenue were dismissed.

Why Read This Judgment?

The judgment provides significant guidance on the distinction between statutory product declarations and commercial branding under GST exemption notifications. It is relevant for Advocates, Chartered Accountants, Company Secretaries, GST Practitioners, Tax Consultants, corporate tax teams, food-processing businesses and manufacturers supplying goods to institutional consumers. The ruling also clarifies the treatment of institutional packages after the introduction of the expression “pre-packaged and labelled” and reiterates that advance rulings do not bind the GST Appellate Tribunal.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY