Home Case Laws Gujarat HC Rules Assignment of Leasehold Rights Not Liable to GST

Gujarat HC Rules Assignment of Leasehold Rights Not Liable to GST

0
540

Case Details:

  • Case Name: M/s Life Sciences Chemicals vs. Union of India & Ors.

  • Court: High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad

  • Petition Nos.: R/Special Civil Application No. 2086 of 2025 & R/Special Civil Application No. 4065 of 2025

  • Date of Judgment: 30 April 2025

  • Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bhargav D. Karia & Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.N. Ray

  • Category of Dispute: GST – Classification & Taxability of Assignment of Leasehold Rights

  • Relevant Sections: Sections 7, 9, 74 of CGST Act, 2017; Schedule II – Entry 2(a) & 5(b); Schedule III – Entry 5; Gujarat GST Act, 2017.


Facts of the Case (Para 6.1–6.6)

  1. The petitioner, a sole proprietorship owned by Ms. Anishaben Sureshbhai Paneliya, was registered under GST from 15.03.2018 to 31.03.2020.

  2. Before this, a partnership firm (same trade name) owned an industrial plot allotted in 2013, which was transferred to the proprietorship in 2017.

  3. The department issued a notice in June 2024 to the erstwhile partnership, demanding GST @ 18% on ₹20,78,550 for transfer of leasehold rights.

  4. Petitioner contended:

    • The transaction was akin to sale of land (Schedule III, Entry 5) and outside GST scope.

    • Transfer was an internal reorganization from partnership to proprietorship.

    • If taxable, GST could apply only on 40% share acquired, not full amount.

  5. Despite these contentions, an order under Section 74 (Form DRC-07) dated 07.11.2024 confirmed tax demand of ₹2,61,144, interest ₹3,32,648, penalty ₹2,61,144.


Questions in Consideration (Para 7–8)

  1. Whether assignment of leasehold rights of industrial land amounts to a taxable “supply” under Section 7(1)(a) of the CGST Act.

  2. Whether such assignment is covered under the exclusion in Schedule III (sale of land) and hence outside GST.

  3. Whether the departmental order under Section 74 was without jurisdiction.


Observation of Court (Para 8–10)

  1. The Court reiterated that under Section 7(2)(a) read with Schedule III, sale of land is not a supply under GST.

  2. Assignment of leasehold rights constitutes transfer of benefits arising from immovable property, which falls outside GST ambit as held in Gujarat Chamber of Commerce and Industry v. Union of India (SCA No. 11345 of 2023, Para 83–84).

  3. Multiple earlier rulings (Alfa Tools Pvt. Ltd., BVM Pharma, Time Technoplast) have followed this principle.

  4. Revenue could not controvert these submissions.


Judgment of Court (Para 11–12)

  • The Court quashed:

    1. Order dated 07.11.2024 under Section 74 in SCA No. 2086/2025.

    2. Order dated 02.01.2025, SCN dated 26.07.2024, and CBIC Circular No. 44/18/2018-CGST dated 02.05.2018 in SCA No. 4065/2025.

  • Petitions allowed; Rule made absolute; No costs.


Between Fine Lines

In simple words, the Gujarat High Court held that transferring leasehold rights in industrial land is essentially a transfer of immovable property, not a taxable supply under GST. Therefore, the tax, interest, and penalty imposed were set aside. This follows earlier High Court rulings confirming such transactions are outside GST scope.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
Gujarat Chamber of Commerce and Industry v. Union of India SCA No. 11345 of 2023, 2025 SCC OnLine Guj 537 Held that assignment of leasehold rights in land is transfer of immovable property, not liable to GST GST not applicable
Alfa Tools Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India 2025:GUJHC;15785-C Applied Gujarat Chamber ruling to similar leasehold transfer GST not applicable
BVM Pharma v. Union of India SCA No. 2429 of 2025 Followed same principle for transfer of leasehold rights GST not applicable
Time Technoplast Ltd. v. Union of India SCA No. 14293 of 2024 Applied Gujarat Chamber reasoning to leasehold right transfer GST not applic

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY