Case Summary
Case Title: M/s Forging India Iron and Steel Limited vs Union of India and Ors.
Court: Calcutta High Court
Petition Nos.: MAT/337/2025 and MAT/384/2025, IA No. CAN/1/2025
Category: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Cross-examination rights and adjudication procedure
Date of Judgment: 25 March 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 107(1) of the CGST Act, 2017; provisions relating to ITC and appeals under CGST Rules.
Facts (Para 1–3)
The case involved two connected appeals – one by the assessee company, M/s Forging India Iron and Steel Limited, and another by the tax department. The dispute centered on the writ court’s decision permitting cross-examination of one Shri Niraj Kumar Nathani, whose statement was used during investigation into alleged wrongful availment of ITC based on fake documents. While the company challenged certain parts of the order, the department contested the entire order.
Questions in Dispute (Para 2–4)
The core issues were:
-
Whether the assessee could rely on the right to cross-examine Shri Niraj Kumar Nathani, whose statement was used in the investigation.
-
Whether the writ court was justified in entertaining factual disputes instead of relegating the matter to the appellate forum.
-
Whether the ITC disallowance could be sustained solely based on corroborative statements or whether other independent evidence sufficed.
Observations of the Court (Para 4–8)
The High Court noted that the department itself admitted that the impugned statement was merely corroborative and not the sole basis for the order-in-original. Other material evidence, such as the inspection report from the Bureau of Investigation and statements of the company directors, were available. Therefore, the assessee should not insist on cross-examination of a corroborative witness. The Court also held that several factual controversies existed, which were inappropriate for resolution in writ jurisdiction.
Judgement (Para 8–13)
The Division Bench set aside the writ court’s order and directed the assessee to file a statutory appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) under Section 107(1) of the CGST Act. Importantly, the appellate authority was instructed to decide the matter without reference to the statement of Shri Niraj Kumar Nathani, while adjudicating all other issues on merits. Since the limitation period had expired, the Court allowed the assessee 45 days from receipt of the order to file the appeal manually, subject to pre-deposit compliance. All issues were left open for adjudication.
Table of Cases Referred
| Case Referred | Court’s Summary / Verdict |
|---|---|
| Investigation report of Bureau of Investigation, WB | Treated as substantive material evidence against assessee |
| Statements of Directors | Treated as primary evidence supporting ITC denial |
| Statement of Shri Niraj Kumar Nathani | Held to be only corroborative, not central to adjudication |
Between Fine Lines
For businesses, this case underscores that writ petitions are not the proper remedy where factual disputes over ITC are involved. The proper course is to exhaust the statutory appellate mechanism under Section 107. Importantly, the Court clarified that corroborative statements alone cannot prejudice an assessee, ensuring that appeals will be decided on substantive evidence and merits.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




