The Himachal Pradesh High Court, in M/s H.M. Steels Limited v. The Joint Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise and Anr., CWP No. 6800 of 2024, decided on 9 April 2026, considered the statutory restriction against parallel GST proceedings under Section 6(2)(b) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. The dispute concerned action taken by State and Central GST authorities in relation to the petitioner and whether proceedings by one authority could continue when the other authority had already initiated action concerning the same subject matter.
Background of the Dispute
The petitioner approached the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging proceedings on the ground that they were without jurisdiction and contrary to Section 6 of the CGST Act and the corresponding provisions of the Himachal Pradesh GST Act.
The petitioner contended that the State GST authorities had initiated an inquiry first and, therefore, the Central GST authorities could not initiate further proceedings concerning the same subject matter. The record showed that the State Authority had issued summons dated 12 February 2024 and 13 February 2024, followed by an intimation in FORM GST DRC-01A dated 27 June 2024. The Central Authority had also issued summons under Section 70 of the CGST Act in April and May 2024.
Section 6(2)(b) and Parallel GST Proceedings
The High Court observed that the principal controversy stood substantially settled by the Supreme Court in M/s Armour Security (India) Ltd. v. Commissioner, CGST, Delhi East & Anr., AIR 2025 SC 3854.
The Supreme Court had clarified that Section 6(2)(b) bars initiation of proceedings by another GST authority on the same subject matter once adjudicatory proceedings have already been formally initiated. Importantly, the expression “initiation of any proceedings” refers to the formal commencement of adjudication through issuance of a show cause notice. Investigative measures such as summons, search or seizure do not, by themselves, constitute initiation of proceedings for purposes of Section 6(2)(b).
The Supreme Court had further explained that “subject matter” refers to the tax liability, deficiency or obligation arising from a particular alleged contravention. Where two proceedings seek to assess or recover an identical or overlapping liability arising from the same contravention, the statutory bar becomes applicable.
Investigation Can Continue, but Duplicate Adjudication Cannot
Applying the principles laid down in Armour Security, the High Court recognised the distinction between an inquiry or investigation and formal adjudicatory proceedings.
The Court reiterated that bona fide investigative steps, including summons issued under Section 70 of the CGST Act, may continue until it is established that both Central and State authorities are examining the same liability or contravention. However, once the authorities identify an overlap concerning the same subject matter, they must coordinate and ensure that the taxpayer is not subjected to multiple adjudicatory proceedings for the same liability.
Coordination Between Central and State GST Authorities
The High Court directed the petitioner to appear before the Central Authority and raise its objections, together with relevant documents, in accordance with the Supreme Court’s directions in Armour Security.
The petitioner was also required to comply with the summons and the DRC-01A proceedings and to inform the authorities about the overlapping action. Thereafter, the State Authority was directed to communicate with the Central Authority and verify the petitioner’s claim.
Both GST authorities were specifically required to coordinate so that the assessee was not subjected to multiple adjudicatory processes on the same subject matter. The competent adjudicating authority was then directed to proceed in accordance with law after providing an opportunity of hearing.
High Court Does Not Decide Merits
The High Court clarified that it had expressed no opinion on the merits of the allegations or upon the validity of the show cause notice, summons or notices. All rights and contentions of the parties were kept open for consideration by the competent authority.
The writ petition was accordingly disposed of with directions intended to implement the mechanism prescribed by the Supreme Court in Armour Security.
Key Legal Takeaway
The judgment reinforces that Section 6(2)(b) of the CGST Act protects taxpayers against duplicate adjudication on the same subject matter, but does not automatically prohibit investigative action such as summons merely because another GST authority has commenced an inquiry. Where Central and State GST investigations overlap, the authorities must communicate and coordinate, identify whether the subject matter is genuinely identical, and ensure that only one adjudicatory process ultimately proceeds in relation to the same liability and contravention.
The decision is significant for taxpayers facing simultaneous action by Central and State GST authorities because it emphasises both taxpayer cooperation during investigation and the statutory protection against multiplicity of adjudicatory proceedings.




