Case:
Centre C Edtech Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Intelligence Officer, SGST & Ors.
Court: High Court of Kerala
Petition No.: WA No. 1934 of 2024 & WA No. 1962 of 2024
Relevant Section: Section 74 of CGST Act, Section 132A of Income Tax Act
Category: Illegal seizure – Goods and Services Tax
Date of Judgement: 27 January 2025
Relevant Provisions:
-
Section 74(1), CGST/SGST Act
-
Articles 265 and 300A, Constitution of India
-
Section 132A, Income Tax Act, 1961
Facts of the Case:
[Para 2–3]
-
Officers of the Kerala SGST Department conducted proceedings under Section 74 of the CGST/SGST Act and seized ₹39,70,760 in cash from the premises of Centre C Edtech Pvt. Ltd. and Gayathri J.A.
-
The seized cash was kept in the District Treasury and later handed over to the Income Tax Department on 26.03.2024 under Section 132A of the Income Tax Act.
[Para 4]
-
The appellants filed writ petitions for the return of seized cash, asserting that cash is not ‘goods’ or ‘stock-in-trade’ under GST, hence not liable for seizure under GST laws.
Question(s) in Consideration:
[Para 5–7]
-
Whether the GST Department is empowered under Section 74 of the CGST/SGST Act to seize cash that is not part of stock-in-trade?
-
Whether subsequent transfer of such cash to the Income Tax Department under a requisition under Section 132A of the IT Act cures the illegality of the original seizure?
Observation of Court:
[Para 7]
-
The Court held the initial seizure by the GST Department was without jurisdiction and blatantly illegal since cash not forming stock-in-trade cannot be seized under CGST/SGST Act.
-
Reiterated constitutional principles under Articles 265 and 300A that prohibit expropriation of property without authority of law.
[Para 7]
-
Referred to Sabu George v. Sales Tax Officer (IB) [(2023) 153 Taxman.com 46] and Supreme Court affirmation [(2023) 153 Taxman.com 138], holding that cash cannot be seized by GST officers unless it constitutes goods/stock-in-trade.
Judgement of the Court:
[Para 8]
-
Declared seizure of cash by GST Department illegal.
-
Directed Income Tax Department to release ₹10,58,860 to appellant in WA 1934/2024 and ₹29,11,900 to appellant in WA 1962/2024 within 10 days.
-
Proceedings under Section 74 CGST Act and Section 132A IT Act can continue independently from their present stages, but without treating the seizure as valid under law.
Between Fine Lines:
-
GST Officers cannot seize cash unless it is proven as stock-in-trade.
-
Illegal seizure cannot be validated retrospectively through handover to another authority.
-
Seizure powers must strictly comply with statutory limitations.
-
Citizens’ property rights are protected under Articles 265 and 300A.
-
Officers must act within the bounds of established legal precedents.
Summary of Referred Cases:
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sabu George & Ors. v. STO (IB) & Ors. | (2023) 153 Taxman.com 46 | Held GST authorities cannot seize cash unless it’s part of stock-in-trade. | Seizure of cash by GST held impermissible. |
| STO (IB) & Ors. v. Sabu George & Ors. | (2023) 153 Taxman.com 138 (SC) | Supreme Court confirmed Kerala HC’s view on illegal cash seizure under GST. | Upheld High Court’s ruling against GST dept. |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




