Home Case Laws Illegal GST Seizure of Cash Quashed; High Court Orders Return of Money

Illegal GST Seizure of Cash Quashed; High Court Orders Return of Money

0
347

Case:
Centre C Edtech Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Intelligence Officer, SGST & Ors.
Court: High Court of Kerala
Petition No.: WA No. 1934 of 2024 & WA No. 1962 of 2024
Relevant Section: Section 74 of CGST Act, Section 132A of Income Tax Act
Category: Illegal seizure – Goods and Services Tax
Date of Judgement: 27 January 2025
Relevant Provisions:

  • Section 74(1), CGST/SGST Act

  • Articles 265 and 300A, Constitution of India

  • Section 132A, Income Tax Act, 1961


Facts of the Case:

[Para 2–3]

  • Officers of the Kerala SGST Department conducted proceedings under Section 74 of the CGST/SGST Act and seized ₹39,70,760 in cash from the premises of Centre C Edtech Pvt. Ltd. and Gayathri J.A.

  • The seized cash was kept in the District Treasury and later handed over to the Income Tax Department on 26.03.2024 under Section 132A of the Income Tax Act.

[Para 4]

  • The appellants filed writ petitions for the return of seized cash, asserting that cash is not ‘goods’ or ‘stock-in-trade’ under GST, hence not liable for seizure under GST laws.


Question(s) in Consideration:

[Para 5–7]

  • Whether the GST Department is empowered under Section 74 of the CGST/SGST Act to seize cash that is not part of stock-in-trade?

  • Whether subsequent transfer of such cash to the Income Tax Department under a requisition under Section 132A of the IT Act cures the illegality of the original seizure?


Observation of Court:

[Para 7]

  • The Court held the initial seizure by the GST Department was without jurisdiction and blatantly illegal since cash not forming stock-in-trade cannot be seized under CGST/SGST Act.

  • Reiterated constitutional principles under Articles 265 and 300A that prohibit expropriation of property without authority of law.

[Para 7]

  • Referred to Sabu George v. Sales Tax Officer (IB) [(2023) 153 Taxman.com 46] and Supreme Court affirmation [(2023) 153 Taxman.com 138], holding that cash cannot be seized by GST officers unless it constitutes goods/stock-in-trade.


Judgement of the Court:

[Para 8]

  • Declared seizure of cash by GST Department illegal.

  • Directed Income Tax Department to release ₹10,58,860 to appellant in WA 1934/2024 and ₹29,11,900 to appellant in WA 1962/2024 within 10 days.

  • Proceedings under Section 74 CGST Act and Section 132A IT Act can continue independently from their present stages, but without treating the seizure as valid under law.


Between Fine Lines:

  1. GST Officers cannot seize cash unless it is proven as stock-in-trade.

  2. Illegal seizure cannot be validated retrospectively through handover to another authority.

  3. Seizure powers must strictly comply with statutory limitations.

  4. Citizens’ property rights are protected under Articles 265 and 300A.

  5. Officers must act within the bounds of established legal precedents.


Summary of Referred Cases:

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
Sabu George & Ors. v. STO (IB) & Ors. (2023) 153 Taxman.com 46 Held GST authorities cannot seize cash unless it’s part of stock-in-trade. Seizure of cash by GST held impermissible.
STO (IB) & Ors. v. Sabu George & Ors. (2023) 153 Taxman.com 138 (SC) Supreme Court confirmed Kerala HC’s view on illegal cash seizure under GST. Upheld High Court’s ruling against GST dept.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY