Home Case Laws Imposition of tax and penalty under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act,...

Imposition of tax and penalty under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 is not sustainable where taxpayer has not come forward to make payment for provisionally release of detained goods.

0
620

Case Title: State of Uttar Pradesh vs Maa Vindhyavasini Tobacco (P.) Ltd.

Court: High Court of Allahabad

Petition No.: Writ C No. 20203 of 2019

Category of Dispute: Detention and Penalty – Section 129 of the CGST Act

Date of Judgement: 20 October 2022

Relevant Sections: Section 129(1), 129(3), 122, Chapter 15 & 19 of CGST Act; Rule 138 of CGST Rules

 

Facts of the Case

  1. The respondent company was transporting goods which were intercepted on 28-04-2019 based on intelligence alleging that the goods were being transported again using pre-used tax invoices [Para 3].
  2. Statement of the truck driver was recorded. Based on it, a notice under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act was issued, demanding tax of ₹7,23,700 and cess of ₹19,05,024 [Para 3].
  3. The respondent filed an appeal, and the appellate authority set aside the order dated 17-05-2019 on grounds of absence of material evidence to support seizure and detention [Para 3].

Questions in Consideration

  1. Whether the interception and detention of goods solely based on the allegation of using pre-used invoices was valid under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act? [Para 2–4]
  2. Whether the appellate authority rightly held that presumption without material evidence cannot sustain tax and penalty imposition under Section 129(3)? [Para 3–4]

Observations of the Court

  1. The Court held that no evidence was provided regarding the alleged misuse of invoices or reuse of E-way bills under Rule 138, nor was it reflected in the assessment order [Para 4].
  2. The appellate authority was right in observing that levy of tax and penalty cannot rest on presumptions and should be backed by concrete material evidence [Para 3–4].
  3. The Court clarified that Section 129 provides a mechanism to release detained goods upon payment and is an alternative to regular assessment proceedings under Chapter 15 and Section 122 [Para 5].
  4. Since the respondent did not opt for the Section 129(1) benefit voluntarily, the department could have initiated proceedings under Chapter 15, which was not done [Para 5–6].

 

Judgement of the Court

The High Court dismissed the writ petition filed by the State of U.P., upheld the appellate authority’s decision setting aside the penalty and tax demand under Section 129(3), and vacated the interim order [Para 7].

 

Between Fine Lines

  • Tax and penalty under Section 129(3) cannot be imposed based solely on presumption or unverified intelligence.
  • The absence of evidence like duplicate E-way bills weakens the department’s case.
  • Section 129 offers a voluntary settlement option, not a mandatory penal measure.
  • Department may proceed under Chapter 15 for regular adjudication if Section 129 route is not taken.
  • Courts will not interfere under Article 226 if findings are based on facts and due process.

Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
No specific case law referred by name in this judgment — The judgment is based on statutory interpretation and facts without citing external precedents —

LEAVE A REPLY