Case Details
-
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
-
Petition Nos.: Writ Tax No. 1282, 1285, 1287, 1288 & 1289 of 2024
-
Petitioner: M/s Solvi Enterprises
-
Respondents: Additional Commissioner Grade-2 & Others
-
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit – Section 16, Section 74 CGST/UPGST Act, Rule 36 CGST Rules
-
Date of Judgement: 24.03.2025
-
Relevant Sections: Sections 16 & 74 CGST/UPGST Act, Rule 36 CGST Rules
Facts (Paras 2–8)
M/s Solvi Enterprises, a registered dealer engaged in scrap trading, purchased goods in December 2018 from M/s Radhey International, a registered GST dealer. The supplier’s registration was later cancelled with effect from January 2020. Despite valid registration at the time of supply, the department issued notice under Section 74 alleging wrongful ITC, contending that the seller was non-existent. The petitioner argued that invoices were genuine, GSTR-1 and 3B were filed, and GSTR-2A reflected the purchase, hence ITC could not be denied merely due to later cancellation.
Questions (Para 14, 22–24)
The central issue before the Court was whether ITC can be denied to a purchaser when the seller was duly registered at the time of supply and returns were filed, merely because the seller’s registration was cancelled at a later date.
Observations (Paras 16–21, 25–31)
The Court examined Section 16 (eligibility of ITC), Section 74 (wrongful ITC due to fraud/misstatement) and Rule 36 (documentary requirements). It noted:
-
At the time of transaction (06.12.2018), the seller was validly registered.
-
Registration was cancelled prospectively from 29.01.2020, not retrospectively.
-
GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B were filed; GSTR-2A auto-populated for the purchaser, evidencing genuineness.
-
Authorities ignored these filings and instead held the purchaser liable without verifying portal data on tax payment.
-
Precedents like Rajshi Processors and Shiv Trading were distinguished as those involved cancellation from inception or non-filing of returns. The Court relied on Rama Brick Field (Writ Tax No. 909 of 2022) to hold that valid registration at the time of transaction protects ITC claim.
Judgement (Paras 32–35)
The Court held that denial of ITC was unsustainable since the seller was registered at the relevant time and records evidenced compliance. The impugned orders were quashed. The matter was remanded to the authorities to pass a fresh speaking order within two months. Any deposit by the petitioner pursuant to impugned orders would be subject to final outcome.
Case Law References
| Case | Court | Principle / Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| State of Karnataka v. Ecom Gill Coffee Trading Pvt. Ltd. (2023 SC) | Supreme Court | Denial of ITC when seller was unregistered and returns not filed – held against purchaser. |
| M/s Rajshi Processors Raebareli v. State of U.P. (2024 AHC) | Allahabad HC | ITC denied as supplier was non-existent and registration cancelled ab initio. |
| M/s Shiv Trading v. State of U.P. (2023 AHC, SLP dismissed 2024 SC) | Allahabad HC upheld by SC | ITC denial sustained where seller non-existent and GSTR verification not supported. |
| M/s Rama Brick Field v. Addl. Commissioner (2022 AHC) | Allahabad HC | ITC denial quashed as seller was registered at transaction time and returns filed – authorities failed to verify GST portal data. |
Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)
For businesses, this judgment reinforces that ITC cannot be denied merely because the supplier’s registration is later cancelled, provided the supplier was registered at the time of supply, invoices are genuine, and returns are filed. Authorities must verify portal data instead of shifting the burden entirely on buyers. Trade should ensure invoices match GST portal filings (GSTR-1/2A/3B) to safeguard ITC claims.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




