Case Summary
Case Title: M/s Bhavani Tractor v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 13787 of 2024
Judgment Date: 10 July 2025
Category of Dispute: Interest and Penalty – Input Tax Credit adjustment
Relevant Sections: Sections 50, 73, 74, 75(2), 107, 128A of CGST Act; Rule 88B & Rule 164 of CGST Rules
Facts (Para 3.1–3.7)
The petitioner, an authorized dealer of Mahindra Tractors and GST registrant, had an outstanding tax liability of ₹51,12,570 for FY 2019–20. Although sufficient ITC was available in the electronic credit ledger, the offset was not done in time. During audit, authorities raised queries, and the petitioner discharged liability by filing DRC-03 on 05.01.2023 under Section 73(5) and also paid tax and penalty under Section 74(5) to avoid litigation. However, authorities continued to pursue interest and penalty on grounds of delayed offset, eventually confirming demand under Section 74 by Order-in-Original dated 20.10.2023 and appellate order dated 14.06.2024.
Questions in Dispute
-
Whether interest under Section 50 and penalty under Section 74 were sustainable when sufficient ITC was available but not timely offset.
-
Whether the petitioner’s conduct amounted to suppression to justify invoking Section 74 instead of Section 73.
-
Whether the benefit of newly inserted Section 128A (waiver of interest/penalty for FY 2017–18 to 2019–20) could be extended.
Observations (Para 4.1–6)
The Court noted:
-
The petitioner had sufficient ITC and had discharged liability through DRC-03, hence no malafide or suppression was established.
-
Invocation of Section 74 was unjustified; mere delay in offset did not amount to suppression.
-
With the insertion of Section 128A effective 01.11.2024, the legislature intended to waive interest/penalty demands raised under Section 73 for the relevant years.
-
Circular No. 238/32/2024-GST and 53rd GST Council Meeting minutes confirmed legislative intent for conditional waiver, provided proceedings are aligned with Section 73.
Judgment (Para 7–8)
The Court quashed orders under Section 74 and remanded the matter to the adjudicating authority with directions:
-
To pass a fresh de novo order under Section 73 instead of Section 74.
-
To grant opportunity of hearing to the petitioner within three months.
-
This would enable the petitioner to claim waiver of interest/penalty under Section 128A.
The petition was disposed of with no order as to costs.
Table: Cases/References Considered
| Case/Reference | Court/Source | Verdict/Observation |
|---|---|---|
| Finance (No.2) Act, 2024 (inserting Sec.128A) | Parliament | Waiver of interest/penalty for FY 2017–18 to 2019–20 where proceedings under Sec.73 apply |
| 53rd GST Council Meeting, Agenda & Minutes | GST Council | Recommended insertion of Sec.128A to provide conditional waiver |
| Circular No. 238/32/2024-GST dated 15.10.2024 | CBIC | Clarified procedure under Rule 164 for availing Sec.128A benefit |
Between Fine Lines
For taxpayers, this judgment affirms that mere delay in adjusting ITC does not amount to suppression, and penalty under Section 74 cannot be imposed unless malafide intent is proved. With Section 128A in place, businesses facing audit demands for FY 2017–20 can now seek relief by ensuring cases are considered under Section 73, thereby securing waiver of interest and penalty.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




