Home Case Laws Interest on GST refund directed to run from sixty days after the...

Interest on GST refund directed to run from sixty days after the first refund application, as the appellate process is merely a continuation and does not postpone the statutory entitlement

0
193

Case Title: Bansal International v. Commissioner of DGST & Anr.
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 11629/2023
Date of Judgment: 21 November 2023
Category of Dispute: Refund – Interest on Delayed Refund
Relevant Provisions: Sections 54, 56, 107, 112, 117 of the CGST/DGST Act; Rule 89, Rule 90 of the CGST Rules


Facts (paras 1–14, 4.1–4.7)

The petitioner, a proprietor engaged in exports, filed a refund application on 06.02.2020 seeking refund of unutilised ITC amounting to ₹53,92,516 for November 2019. The application was acknowledged on 30.07.2020, accompanied by a show cause notice proposing rejection. The adjudicating authority partly sanctioned a refund of only ₹1,08,293 and rejected the balance on the ground that the petitioner allegedly had no inward supply from Suvidha Enterprises owing to non-generation of e-way bills.

The petitioner appealed. The Appellate Authority, upon verifying the Railway records, held that goods were indeed supplied by U.K. Traders to Suvidha Enterprises, whose supplies in turn were made to the petitioner. The rejection was set aside and the petitioner was permitted to file a fresh application for refund, though interest was denied.

A second refund application dated 23.11.2022 was filed, pursuant to which refund was sanctioned on 28.12.2022 and disbursed on 03.01.2023. On 16.05.2023, the petitioner sought interest of ₹13,12,761 at 9% under Section 56. The adjudicating authority rejected the claim, concluding that the 60-day period must be reckoned from the date of the second refund application filed after the appellate order.


Questions for Determination (paras 2–3, 20–22)

  1. Whether interest under Section 56 of the CGST/DGST Act begins from sixty days after the first refund application filed under Section 54(1), irrespective of subsequent appellate proceedings.

  2. Whether the application filed after the appellate order amounts to a fresh application under Section 54(1), thereby shifting the commencement date for computing interest.

  3. Whether the proviso to Section 56 overrides the main provision and postpones the interest liability.


Court’s Observations (paras 14–35)

The Court observed that Section 56 clearly mandates interest if refund ordered under Section 54(5) is not granted within sixty days of receipt of the application under Section 54(1). The statutory scheme under Sections 54, 56, and Rules 89–90 emphasises that the first complete application, once acknowledged, triggers the statutory clock.

The Court held that appellate proceedings are merely a continuation of the original refund proceedings. An order passed by the Appellate Authority, Tribunal or Court merges with the original order, and by virtue of the Explanation to Section 56, such appellate orders are deemed to be orders under Section 54(5). Hence, the date of the first refund application remains determinative.

The Court rejected the Revenue’s contention that Rule 89(2)(a) requires a fresh application after the appellate order. Accepting such an interpretation would lead to absurdity — it would render legitimate refund claims time-barred because the two-year limitation under Section 54(1) is not extended by the time spent in appeals.

The proviso to Section 56 was construed harmoniously. The Court held that the proviso merely enhances the rate of interest to 9% when refund resulting from an appellate order is not granted within sixty days of the subsequent application. It does not displace the liability to pay 6% interest from the period linked to the first application.

The Court relied on Supreme Court jurisprudence (Tata Chemicals, Modi Industries, Willowood Chemicals) to reaffirm that interest is compensatory for deprivation of lawful funds.

The Punjab & Haryana High Court’s decision in SBI Cards & Payment Services Ltd. was cited with approval for the computation method.


Judgment (paras 34–36)

The High Court allowed the writ petition, set aside the impugned order, and directed the adjudicating authority to process the petitioner’s interest claim in accordance with the Court’s ruling. The petitioner was held entitled to:

  • 6% interest from sixty days after the first refund application dated 06.02.2020 till sixty days after the subsequent application, and

  • 9% interest thereafter until the actual date of refund, if the refund after the appellate order was delayed.


Cases Referred – Summary Table

Case Court Proposition / Verdict
State of Kerala v. K.M. Charia Abdullah & Co., AIR 1965 SC 1585 Supreme Court Appellate proceedings are continuation of original proceedings; doctrine of merger applies.
Gojer Bros v. Ratan Lal Singh, (1974) 2 SCC 453 Supreme Court Appellate order supersedes original order; merger applies.
Tata Chemicals Ltd., (2014) 6 SCC 335 Supreme Court Interest is compensatory; State must compensate unlawful retention of money.
Modi Industries Ltd., (1995) 6 SCC 396 Supreme Court Statutory interest governed by statute; equitable interest applies where statute is silent.
Godavari Sugar Mills, (2011) 2 SCC 439 Supreme Court Interest on delayed refund is compensatory for use of taxpayer’s funds.
Willowood Chemicals, (2022) 9 SCC 341 Supreme Court Interest liability arises statutorily; delay in refund cannot defeat right to compensation.
VKC Footsteps (India) Pvt. Ltd., (2022) 2 SCC 603 Supreme Court Principles of statutory interpretation of provisos; proviso cannot override main enactment.
SBI Cards & Payment Services Ltd. v. UOI, P&H HC (2023) High Court Same interpretation of Section 56; interest runs from first application; enhanced rate applies only after appellate order.

Between the Fine Lines – Trade Takeaway

This judgment reinforces that taxpayers cannot be penalised for departmental errors or prolonged appellate timelines. The refund-interest mechanism under GST begins from the date of the first valid refund application, not from any subsequent applications compelled by appellate success. The ruling restores certainty and prevents administrative delay from eroding the statutory compensatory framework for exporters and refund-based industries.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY