Home Updates ITAT Delhi Holds Sale of Renewable Energy Certificates as Capital Receipt; Excludes...

ITAT Delhi Holds Sale of Renewable Energy Certificates as Capital Receipt; Excludes REC Income from MAT Book Profit

0
108

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench, has held that receipts arising from the sale of Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) are in the nature of capital receipts and consequently cannot be taxed as business income. The Tribunal further upheld their exclusion while computing book profit under Section 115JB of the Income Tax Act.

The decision was rendered in Income Tax Officer, Ward 14(1), New Delhi v. Kapil Mohan and Associates Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. in Revenue appeals concerning Assessment Years 2018-19 and 2020-21.

The assessee was engaged in generation of power through two hydro power projects situated in Himachal Pradesh. During assessment, the Assessing Officer took the view that income arising from trading or sale of REC Bonds was not income derived from the eligible power-generation business. Accordingly, deduction under Section 80IA was denied in respect of such receipts.

In appeal, the CIT(A) treated the proceeds from transfer of RECs as capital receipts. It was held that the certificates represented an entitlement arising from generation of renewable energy and the environmental benefits associated with such activity, rather than consideration for the sale of goods, services or a business by-product. The CIT(A) also held that the receipts should not form part of book profit for purposes of Section 115JB.

REC Receipts Are Capital in Nature

The ITAT noted that Renewable Energy Certificates are issued under a regulatory framework to incentivise generation of electricity from renewable energy sources. Referring to earlier judicial decisions dealing with carbon credits, RECs and Energy Saving Certificates, the Tribunal observed that such entitlements arise principally from environmental considerations and measures intended to reduce carbon emissions.

The Tribunal particularly relied upon the decisions in Satia Industries Ltd. and DCM Shri Ram Industries Ltd., where receipts from RECs had been regarded as capital in nature. It noted that the Delhi Tribunal in DCM Shri Ram Industries Ltd. had already held that the sale of REC Bonds constitutes a capital receipt and that such receipts are not includible while computing book profit under Section 115JB.

An important aspect highlighted in the judgment is the distinction between Renewable Energy Certificates and carbon credits. The Tribunal referred to the principle that taxing provisions must be construed strictly and noted that Section 115BBG specifically deals with carbon credits as defined therein. RECs and carbon credits therefore cannot automatically be treated as synonymous merely because both are connected with environmental objectives.

Section 80IA Question Becomes Inapplicable

The Assessing Officer had proceeded on the basis that receipts from the sale of REC Bonds were not derived from the eligible undertaking and therefore did not qualify for deduction under Section 80IA.

The Tribunal, however, upheld the finding that the receipts themselves were capital receipts. Once the receipt was held to be capital in nature, the question whether such income qualified for deduction under Section 80IA ceased to arise.

The ITAT accordingly found no error in the CIT(A)’s conclusion that income from sale of REC Bonds was a capital receipt and that there was no question of examining the allowability of Section 80IA deduction in respect of such receipt.

REC Receipts Also Excluded from MAT Book Profit

The Tribunal further affirmed that the REC receipts, being capital receipts, were required to be excluded while computing book profit under Section 115JB for Minimum Alternate Tax purposes.

Following the earlier coordinate Bench ruling in DCM Shri Ram Industries Ltd., the ITAT accepted that receipts from sale of RECs, being capital in character, should not form part of book profit for Section 115JB computation.

Final Decision

The ITAT dismissed all grounds raised by the Revenue in both appeals and upheld the relief granted by the CIT(A). Consequently, the treatment of proceeds from sale of Renewable Energy Certificates as capital receipts, along with their exclusion from book profit under Section 115JB, was sustained.

Both Revenue appeals in ITA Nos. 7818 and 7819/DEL/2025 for Assessment Years 2018-19 and 2020-21 were dismissed.

The ruling is significant for renewable-energy businesses earning consideration from RECs, particularly on the distinction between environmental incentive receipts and ordinary operational or business income, as well as their treatment under Sections 80IA and 115JB of the Income Tax Act.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY