The Hyderabad Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has remanded the case of Prasad Nimmagadda v. ACIT, Circle 17(2) to the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), granting the assessee another opportunity to produce evidence regarding the source of credits in a Singapore bank account and related issues concerning foreign salary and foreign tax credit. The Tribunal held that, considering the peculiar facts of the case, the matter deserved reconsideration in the interest of justice.
The appeal arose from additions made by the Assessing Officer towards unexplained credits in the assessee’s Singapore OCBC Bank account and the taxation of foreign salary. During appellate proceedings, the assessee contended that he was unable to effectively prosecute the matter because he had remained in judicial custody for more than two years in connection with criminal proceedings relating to certain financial transactions. It was also submitted that the related proceedings were pending before the Supreme Court, preventing him from gathering and producing relevant evidence.
The Revenue opposed the request for another opportunity, pointing out that multiple opportunities had already been granted during assessment as well as appellate proceedings. The CIT(A) had also forwarded additional evidence to the Assessing Officer for a remand report, but the assessee failed to rebut the findings or furnish satisfactory explanations regarding the credits appearing in the foreign bank account. Consequently, the additions under Section 68 of the Income-tax Act were confirmed.
After examining the record, the Tribunal observed that the assessee had demonstrated exceptional circumstances arising from his prolonged custody and the pending criminal litigation. Taking note of these peculiar facts, the ITAT considered it appropriate to provide one final opportunity to substantiate the source of the foreign bank credits and other claims. Accordingly, it set aside the order of the CIT(A) and remanded the matter for fresh adjudication after granting adequate opportunity of hearing to the assessee. The appeal was allowed for statistical purposes.
Why This Judgment Matters
This ruling highlights that appellate authorities and the Tribunal may exercise discretion to restore matters where exceptional circumstances have prevented an assessee from effectively presenting evidence. The decision reinforces the importance of principles of natural justice while also emphasizing that the burden of proving the source of unexplained credits under Section 68 remains with the assessee.
Professionals dealing with foreign bank accounts, cross-border income, unexplained credit additions, foreign tax credit claims, and appellate litigation will find this decision useful in understanding when remand may be justified due to genuine inability to present evidence.




