The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Mumbai Bench “B”, in DCIT-3(1)(1), Mumbai v. Bhavna Bharat Daftary, has held that an Assessing Officer cannot substitute the actual consideration received on an earlier transfer of unquoted shares with the higher consideration arising from a subsequent and independent transaction unless such substitution is expressly authorised by the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue’s appeal and upheld the deletion of additions aggregating to ₹97,02,60,256.
Background of the Dispute
The assessee held substantial equity shares in Bharat Serums and Vaccines Limited (BSVL), an unlisted company. On 30 September 2019, the assessee transferred 5,95,500 shares of BSVL to Aksipro Diagnostics Private Limited (ADPL) at ₹265 per share. At that stage, ADPL was equally owned by the assessee and his brother and the transaction was stated to be an internal restructuring for consolidation of the family’s BSVL shareholding.
The fair market value determined under Rule 11UA on the date of this transfer was ₹257.20 per share. Thus, the actual transfer price of ₹265 per share was higher than the prescribed fair market value.
Subsequently, a Definitive Agreement was executed on 18 November 2019 with Anasamira Limited, an Advent Group company. Following fulfilment of contractual conditions and infusion of capital, ADPL came under the control of the Advent Group on 6 February 2020. On 7 February 2020, the assessee transferred a further 12,56,053 BSVL shares to ADPL at approximately ₹1,893.98 per share.
Assessing Officer Adopts Later Sale Price for Earlier Transfer
During assessment, the Assessing Officer sought to apply the substantially higher consideration relating to the February 2020 transaction to the shares transferred in September 2019.
The AO substituted the contractual consideration of ₹265 per share for the first transfer with approximately ₹1,894.09 per share and consequently made an addition of about ₹97.01 crore, apart from another adjustment of ₹1.37 lakh.
The AO principally relied upon the fact that money relating to the earlier transfer was ultimately received on 7 February 2020 and upon newspaper reports suggesting that negotiations for acquisition of BSVL had commenced earlier.
The CIT(A) deleted the additions, following which the Revenue approached the ITAT.
Section 48 Requires Actual Consideration From the Relevant Transfer
The Tribunal examined the statutory scheme under Sections 2(47), 45, 48 and 50CA of the Income-tax Act.
It held that Section 48 requires capital gains to be computed with reference to the full value of consideration received or accruing as a result of the particular transfer. The Assessing Officer cannot substitute that consideration with an amount which, in his opinion, ought to have been received unless the Act expressly provides for such substitution.
The Tribunal relied upon the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in CIT v. George Henderson & Co. Ltd., CIT v. Gillanders Arbuthnot & Co. Ltd. and K.P. Varghese v. ITO, reiterating that notional market value cannot ordinarily replace the consideration actually accruing from the transfer in the absence of statutory authority.
Section 50CA Was Not Applicable
A crucial aspect of the ruling was the applicability of Section 50CA, which provides for substitution of consideration in specified cases involving transfer of unquoted shares where the declared consideration is lower than the prescribed fair market value.
Here, the Rule 11UA value of the shares on 30 September 2019 was ₹257.20 per share, whereas the assessee had transferred them for ₹265 per share.
Accordingly, the Tribunal found that Section 50CA itself was not attracted. Once the statutory provision permitting substitution did not apply, the AO could not devise another method of replacing the declared consideration with the price prevailing in a later transaction.
The Tribunal observed that creation of such an additional deeming fiction through administrative interpretation would be impermissible in fiscal legislation.
Deferred Receipt Does Not Change the Date of Transfer
The Revenue contended that because the money relating to the September 2019 transaction was received in February 2020, the transactions should effectively be treated together.
The ITAT rejected this reasoning. It held that capital gains arise upon the transfer of the capital asset, and the subsequent timing or manner of payment does not ordinarily alter the date on which the transfer occurred.
The September 2019 transfer was independently evidenced by delivery instructions acknowledged by HDFC Bank and the corresponding debit in the assessee’s demat account. The consideration was also reflected in the running account maintained between the assessee and ADPL.
The later settlement of the outstanding amount therefore could not retrospectively postpone the completed transfer.
Two Transfers Were Commercially and Legally Distinct
The Tribunal also rejected the Revenue’s attempt to treat the September 2019 and February 2020 transfers as one composite transaction.
On 30 September 2019, ADPL was a family-controlled entity and the transfer represented an internal consolidation of shareholding. By February 2020, after capital infusion by Anasamira Limited, ADPL had become controlled by the Advent Group and the subsequent share transfer formed part of an independent third-party acquisition.
The ownership structure, commercial setting, contractual obligations and pricing mechanisms were therefore materially different.
Significantly, even the Definitive Agreement dated 18 November 2019 did not contain a crystallised final sale price. The consideration was dependent upon satisfaction of conditions precedent, due diligence and eventual closing of the transaction. Therefore, the Tribunal found no basis for concluding that the February 2020 consideration had already been predetermined on 30 September 2019.
Newspaper Reports Cannot Override Primary Evidence
The Tribunal further rejected reliance on newspaper reports concerning proposed negotiations for the acquisition of BSVL.
It observed that newspaper reports by themselves do not constitute substantive proof of the facts reported unless independently established. More importantly, the primary contractual evidence demonstrated that the final consideration remained undetermined even on 18 November 2019.
The Definitive Agreement and contemporaneous transaction documents therefore prevailed over speculative conclusions based on media reports.
ITAT Upholds Deletion of ₹97.02 Crore Addition
The Tribunal concluded that the September 2019 transfer was supported by contemporaneous documentary evidence and was independent of the February 2020 transaction.
Since the transfer price of ₹265 per share exceeded the Rule 11UA fair market value of ₹257.20, Section 50CA was inapplicable. No other provision authorised the AO to substitute the actual consideration arising from the earlier completed transfer with the consideration received in a subsequent transaction.
Accordingly, the ITAT affirmed the CIT(A)’s order deleting the addition and dismissed the Revenue’s appeal.
Key Takeaway
The ruling reinforces that computation of capital gains must remain within the statutory framework. Where unquoted shares are transferred for consideration exceeding the fair market value determined under Rule 11UA, Section 50CA cannot be invoked. In the absence of another specific statutory provision, the Assessing Officer cannot replace the actual consideration with a higher price obtained in a later, commercially distinct transaction merely on assumptions regarding market value, negotiations or subsequent receipt of money.




