Home Updates ITAT: Fresh Allotment of Shares Not Taxable Under Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii)

ITAT: Fresh Allotment of Shares Not Taxable Under Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii)

0
103

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Visakhapatnam Bench, in ACIT, Central Circle-1, Visakhapatnam v. Ramesh Chandra Yarlagadda, has held that a fresh allotment of shares by a company cannot be treated as the receipt of property from another person for the purposes of Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

The consolidated order was passed in ITA Nos. 642 and 643/Viz/2025, along with Cross Objection Nos. 43 and 44/Viz/2025, for Assessment Year 2014-15. The Bench comprised Shri Ravish Sood, Judicial Member, and Shri Omkareshwar Chidara, Accountant Member. The order was pronounced on 15 July 2026.

Background of the Dispute

The Assessing Officer initiated reassessment proceedings after receiving information that Sardar Projects Private Limited had allotted equity shares to the assessees at their face value of ₹10 per share, which was substantially lower than the fair market value determined under Rules 11U and 11UA of the Income-tax Rules, 1962.

In the lead matter involving Ramesh Chandra Yarlagadda, the company had allotted 80,400 shares on 5 April 2013 and a further 82,000 shares on 26 March 2014. The Assessing Officer computed deemed income of ₹5,39,76,840 under Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii) and completed the reassessment under Section 147.

The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) deleted the principal addition of ₹5,35,90,620 by following an earlier decision of the ITAT Visakhapatnam Bench concerning the assessee’s brother. However, the CIT(A) sustained an addition of ₹3,86,220 relating to the later allotment of shares.

The Revenue challenged the deletion, while the assessee filed a cross-objection disputing the applicability of Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii), the valuation adopted by the Assessing Officer and the validity of the reassessment proceedings.

Fresh Allotment Distinguished from Transfer of Shares

The principal issue before the Tribunal was whether newly issued shares allotted by a company could be regarded as property “received” by the allottee from another person.

The Tribunal observed that Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii), as applicable to the relevant assessment year, operated where an individual or Hindu undivided family received shares or securities from another person for consideration lower than their aggregate fair market value.

According to the Tribunal, the statutory expression “receives” necessarily presupposes that the property already existed in the hands of another person before being received by the assessee. A fresh allotment stands on a different footing because the shares come into existence only upon their allotment by the company.

The Tribunal emphasised the established distinction in company law between the allotment of new shares and the transfer of existing shares. An allotment represents the appropriation of a portion of the company’s previously unissued share capital to a person. In contrast, a transfer involves the passing of an already existing share from one shareholder to another.

Section 56 Cannot Be Extended to Creation of New Property

The Tribunal relied upon the Supreme Court’s ruling in Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. CIT, which recognised that allotment results in the creation of shares and does not constitute the transfer of existing shares.

It also followed the Gujarat High Court’s decision in Jigar Jashwantlal Shah v. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax-1 and the Hyderabad Bench decision in Thermodyne Dynamics Private Limited v. ITO. These decisions support the principle that a fresh issue of shares does not amount to the receipt of pre-existing property from another person.

The Tribunal held that the deeming fiction under Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii), being a charging provision, must be strictly construed. In the absence of clear statutory language covering the fresh allotment of shares, the provision could not be extended by implication.

Addition of ₹5.35 Crore Deleted

Applying this principle to the facts, the Tribunal noted that the 80,400 equity shares were admittedly allotted by Sardar Projects Private Limited as part of a fresh issue of share capital. The transaction was not a transfer of shares already held by another person.

Consequently, the essential statutory requirement of receiving property from another person was absent. The Tribunal therefore held that Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii) was not attracted and the addition of ₹5,35,90,620 could not be sustained.

The same reasoning was applied to the connected appeal involving Sireesha Yarlagadda.

Revenue Appeals Dismissed and Cross-Objections Allowed

Since the additions were deleted on the fundamental ground that fresh allotment of shares fell outside Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii), the Tribunal treated the Revenue’s challenge to the CIT(A)’s reliance on the earlier ITAT decision as academic and left that issue open.

The Revenue’s appeals were dismissed, while the cross-objections filed by the assessees were allowed. The CIT(A)’s orders were upheld, though on the reasoning recorded by the Tribunal.

Significance of the Decision

The ruling reinforces the legal distinction between the creation of shares through fresh allotment and the transfer of shares already in existence. It clarifies that the anti-abuse provisions relating to the receipt of property for inadequate consideration cannot be applied merely because newly allotted shares were issued below their computed fair market value.

For Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii) to apply, the statutory requirement of receiving pre-existing property from another person must first be satisfied. A charging provision creating a legal fiction cannot be expanded beyond the language enacted by Parliament.

Download

LEAVE A REPLY