Home Updates Karnataka High Court: GST Cannot Be Deducted from Land Acquisition Compensation

Karnataka High Court: GST Cannot Be Deducted from Land Acquisition Compensation

0
155

The Karnataka High Court has held that Goods and Services Tax cannot be deducted from compensation payable to a landowner when immovable property is compulsorily acquired by the State in exercise of its statutory power of eminent domain. The Court observed that compulsory acquisition of land and structures does not amount to a “supply of goods or services” for the purposes of GST.

The petitioner, Smt. Lalitha S, challenged the deduction of Rs.1,14,815.29 as 18% GST from the compensation awarded for acquisition of her land measuring 10.08 guntas in Sy. No.219/2 of B. Agrahara Village, Srirangapatna Taluk, Mandya District. The land had been acquired for widening the Mysuru–Madikeri Highway. The total compensation determined in respect of the acquired land and structure was Rs.8,89,035.20.

The respondents contended that while compensation attributable to land may not attract GST, the structural component under the award was liable to GST. The High Court, however, rejected this contention. It noted that buildings and structures attached to land form part of immovable property and cannot be regarded as goods merely because a separate valuation may have been assigned to them in the acquisition award.

Referring to Article 366(12A) of the Constitution, the Court observed that GST is a tax on the supply of goods or services or both. Compulsory acquisition of immovable property by the State does not involve a voluntary supply by the landowner. The landowner neither sells goods nor renders any service by surrendering property pursuant to the State’s exercise of eminent domain. Consequently, even a wide interpretation of the expression “supply of goods or services” cannot bring statutory acquisition of immovable property within the GST framework.

The Court also noted that the respondents could not identify any provision under the GST law under which acquisition of land or structures by the State could be treated as a taxable supply. It further referred to a similar matter considered by the Madras High Court, where the National Highways Authority of India had admitted that GST was not applicable on compensation paid for acquisition.

Accordingly, the Karnataka High Court held that the respondents had acted in excess of their authority in deducting GST from the compensation payable to the petitioner.

The Court quashed the award notice dated 7 July 2025 to the extent it provided for deduction of GST. The Special Land Acquisition Officer was directed to refund the deducted GST amount of Rs.1,14,815.29 along with interest at 15% per annum from the date of the award until payment. Significantly, the Court directed that the interest payable on the wrongly deducted GST should be recovered personally from the concerned officer. It also awarded costs of Rs.50,000 to the petitioner, payable within one month.

Key Legal Principle

Compulsory acquisition of land and structures by the State is an exercise of sovereign statutory power and does not constitute a supply of goods or services. Therefore, GST cannot be deducted from compensation payable for such acquisition.

Decision

The writ petition was allowed to the extent indicated by the Court. The GST deduction was quashed, refund with 15% interest was ordered, and costs of Rs.50,000 were awarded to the petitioner.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY