Home Updates Karnataka High Court Upholds Eviction, Recalculates Commercial Lease Arrears in Aria Brew...

Karnataka High Court Upholds Eviction, Recalculates Commercial Lease Arrears in Aria Brew Case

0
144

 

Case: M/s. Aria Brew and Dine Private Limited v. M/s. Century Corbel & Others
Court: High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru
Case No.: Commercial Appeal No. 140 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 28 July 2026
Coram: Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice C.M. Poonacha
Subject: Commercial Lease, Recovery of Rent, Eviction, Registered Agreements, GST on Rent, Compound Interest and Force Majeure

Background

The Karnataka High Court considered a commercial lease dispute between M/s. Aria Brew and Dine Private Limited, the tenant, and M/s. Century Corbel, the landlord. Aria had taken commercial premises in Bengaluru on lease and had entered into a registered Lease Deed dated 31 October 2018, followed by a Supplementary Agreement dated 2 November 2018 and a Modification Deed dated 30 December 2019.

Aria had instituted a suit seeking recovery of ₹6.75 crore, principally contending that ₹5 crore paid under the Supplementary Agreement and Modification Deed was refundable and that the agreements had been obtained through undue influence and coercion. Century denied these allegations and raised a counterclaim for eviction, arrears of rent and amounts payable under the Supplementary Agreement.

The Commercial Court dismissed Aria’s suit and decreed Century’s counterclaim, including eviction and substantial monetary claims. Aria thereafter challenged the counterclaim decree before the Karnataka High Court.

Core Issues Before the High Court

The principal questions before the Court were whether Aria could avoid its obligations under the registered Supplementary Agreement and Modification Deed on allegations of undue influence; whether the order of eviction was sustainable; the correct amount of arrears of rent payable under the registered Lease Deed; whether rent for the COVID-19 period could be waived under the force majeure clause; and the extent to which Century could recover amounts beyond those specifically claimed in its counterclaim.

Registered Agreements Carry a Presumption of Valid Execution

The High Court noted that the Lease Deed, Supplementary Agreement and Modification Deed were all registered documents. Referring to the Supreme Court’s ruling in Prem Singh v. Birbal, the Court reiterated that a registered document carries a presumption of valid execution and that the burden lies upon the person challenging it to rebut that presumption.

Aria had produced no contemporaneous documentary material demonstrating that Century had exercised undue influence, fraud or coercion while the agreements were executed. Apart from the testimony of its Director, no independent evidence was led to establish that the registered instruments were vitiated.

Accordingly, the High Court declined to interfere with the finding that Aria remained bound by the Supplementary Agreement and Modification Deed.

Eviction of Aria Brew Upheld

Under Clause 8.1 of the Lease Deed, Century was entitled to terminate the lease where rent or other charges remained unpaid continuously for two months.

The record showed that Century had specifically invoked this clause in its reply notice dated 6 August 2020 and had called upon Aria to vacate the premises. The Court also found that Aria had been irregular in payment of rent.

The High Court therefore affirmed the Commercial Court’s direction requiring Aria to quit, vacate and hand over possession of the leased premises.

COVID-19 Did Not Automatically Suspend Rent Liability

Aria sought exclusion of rent for the period affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.

The High Court rejected this contention because the Force Majeure clause in the Lease Deed required the affected party to issue notice within seven days of the force majeure event. Aria admittedly did not issue such notice seeking exemption from rent.

The Court therefore held that the Commercial Court was justified in refusing waiver of rent for the COVID-19 period.

High Court Recalculates Rent Arrears

The lease required payment of monthly rent of ₹15,43,185, subject to a 15% escalation every three years. GST at 18% was also payable on the monthly rent.

For the first 36 months, the Court calculated monthly rent inclusive of GST at ₹18,20,958, resulting in ₹6,55,54,488. For the subsequent 15 months, after escalation, monthly rent inclusive of GST was calculated at ₹20,94,101, aggregating to ₹3,14,11,515.

The total rent liability up to the filing of the counterclaim was therefore determined at ₹9,69,66,003.

Against this, Aria was found to have paid ₹5,15,89,797 up to the date of the counterclaim. Consequently, the balance arrears were recalculated at:

₹4,53,76,206

The Court accordingly modified the monetary decree relating to rent arrears to ₹4,53,76,206.

Interest at 2% Compounded Monthly

The Lease Deed expressly provided for interest at 2% per month, compounded monthly, in case of delayed payment.

Although Century was contractually entitled to interest on defaults, the Court noted that sufficient particulars had not been placed on record showing the dates of individual defaults, part-payments and corresponding interest calculations.

The High Court therefore directed that interest on the determined rent arrears of ₹4,53,76,206 would run at 2% compounded every month from 1 February 2023 until payment.

Liability Under the Supplementary Agreement

Under the registered Supplementary Agreement, Aria had agreed to pay ₹11.25 crore. A sum of ₹5 crore was subsequently paid through a banker’s cheque pursuant to the Modification Deed, while the remaining ₹6.25 crore remained payable.

After taking GST into account, Century’s balance claim under the Supplementary Agreement and Modification Deed stood at ₹8,27,50,000.

The High Court held that Aria remained liable for this amount and directed payment of:

₹8,27,50,000 together with interest at 2% compounded every month from 1 July 2020 until payment.

Claims Beyond the Counterclaim Could Not Be Added Through Interim Applications

An important procedural aspect of the judgment concerned claims for maintenance, electricity charges and DG-set costs.

The High Court observed that Century’s counterclaim had sought arrears of rent, whereas some additional amounts towards maintenance, electricity and other charges were later sought through interim applications.

Since those amounts were either outside the counterclaim or related to periods subsequent to its filing, the Court held that they could not be granted in the present proceedings. Century was left free to initiate appropriate separate proceedings in accordance with law for post-counterclaim amounts.

This reinforces the principle that monetary relief must remain confined to the case actually pleaded and claimed before the Court.

Final Verdict

The Karnataka High Court partly allowed the commercial appeal and modified the decree of the Commercial Court.

The direction requiring Aria Brew and Dine Private Limited to quit, vacate and hand over the leased premises was affirmed.

Aria was directed to pay Century:

₹4,53,76,206 as arrears of rent, together with 2% interest compounded monthly from 1 February 2023 until payment; and

₹8,27,50,000 under the Supplementary Agreement and Modification Deed, together with 2% interest compounded monthly from 1 July 2020 until payment.

The decree was modified accordingly.

Legal Takeaway

The judgment highlights that registered commercial agreements cannot ordinarily be avoided through general allegations of coercion or undue influence without cogent evidence capable of rebutting the presumption attached to their valid execution. It also demonstrates that contractual force majeure protection depends upon compliance with the notice mechanism agreed between the parties.

At the same time, even where contractual liability is established, the Court must independently examine the basis of the monetary claim, account for proved payments and ensure that the decree does not extend beyond the relief actually pleaded.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY