The Karnataka High Court, in Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr. v. Shri Ravi Shankar Shetty, has held that an outstanding business advance cannot be treated as income under Section 56(2)(ix) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 merely because it remained unpaid for several years. The Court emphasised that the statutory provision applies only when money is received during negotiations for the transfer of a capital asset, the amount is actually forfeited, and the negotiations do not result in the transfer of that asset.
The judgment was delivered by a Division Bench comprising Justice S.G. Pandit and Justice Rajesh Rai K on 8 July 2026 in Income Tax Appeal No. 225 of 2021. The appeal was filed by the Revenue against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Bengaluru Bench, concerning Assessment Year 2015–16.
Background of the Case
The assessee was engaged in the business of identifying, procuring and facilitating the acquisition of land for real estate projects. He had received advances from Metro Corp and M/s Metro Corp Infrastructure Ltd. under an agreement dated 10 February 2006 for procuring land at Doddaballapur and Chikkaballapur.
As on 31 March 2015, advances aggregating to approximately ₹21.89 crore remained outstanding in the assessee’s books. During scrutiny assessment, the Assessing Officer made an addition of ₹21.11 crore under Section 56(2)(ix), treating the amount as having been virtually forfeited because no refund had been claimed for nearly eight years.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the addition. However, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal deleted it after finding that the essential conditions prescribed under Section 56(2)(ix) had not been satisfied. The Revenue thereafter approached the Karnataka High Court under Section 260A of the Act.
Issue Before the High Court
The principal question before the Court was whether advances received for procuring land could be taxed under Section 56(2)(ix) on the ground that they had remained outstanding for several years and had allegedly been utilised for purchasing assets in the assessee’s own name.
The Revenue contended that the prolonged non-recovery of the amount amounted to virtual forfeiture. It argued that the advances had acquired the character of income because they had neither been returned nor used for transferring the relevant assets to the entities that provided the funds.
The assessee maintained that the advances had not been received during negotiations for the transfer of any capital asset owned by him. The funds were provided for identifying and acquiring land for the business projects of the concerned entities. It was further argued that the proposed land transactions related to stock-in-trade and not capital assets.
Conditions for Applying Section 56(2)(ix)
The High Court examined the language of Section 56(2)(ix), which brings to tax any sum received as an advance or otherwise during negotiations for the transfer of a capital asset where:
the amount is forfeited; and
the negotiations do not result in the transfer of the capital asset.
The Court observed that the legislature had consciously used the word “and”. Therefore, both conditions must be cumulatively satisfied. In addition, the receipt itself must have arisen during negotiations for the transfer of a capital asset.
The receipt of money in the course of negotiations for transferring a capital asset was described as a condition precedent for invoking the provision.
Advances Were Connected With Business Activity
On examining the nature of the arrangement, the Court found that the funds had not been paid for purchasing any capital asset belonging to the assessee. The amounts were entrusted to him for locating, procuring and acquiring lands required for the business projects of Metro Corp and M/s Metro Corp Infrastructure Ltd.
The relationship between the parties was therefore not that of a transferor and transferee negotiating the transfer of a capital asset. Instead, the funds had been provided to the assessee for undertaking a business activity.
The Court further held that land proposed to be acquired in the ordinary course of the assessee’s real estate business would constitute stock-in-trade. Since stock-in-trade is specifically excluded from the definition of “capital asset” under Section 2(14), the first statutory requirement under Section 56(2)(ix) was not fulfilled.
Mere Passage of Time Does Not Constitute Forfeiture
The High Court also rejected the Revenue’s contention that the advances had been virtually forfeited because no refund claim had been made for nearly eight years.
The Court held that mere efflux of time cannot amount to forfeiture. There must be material demonstrating that the recipient has become absolutely entitled to retain the advance.
As on 31 March 2015, the amounts continued to be reflected as liabilities in the assessee’s books. The liabilities had also been confirmed by the entities that provided the advances. In the absence of an express forfeiture or any evidence showing that the assessee had acquired an unconditional right to retain the money, the amount could not be regarded as forfeited.
The Court relied upon the principle stated in CIT v. Alvares & Thomas, where it had been held that mere inability to trace a creditor or the lapse of time does not establish cessation of liability in law.
Decision of the Karnataka High Court
The High Court upheld the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal and held that the requirements of Section 56(2)(ix) were not satisfied.
The advances were not received during negotiations for transferring a capital asset belonging to the assessee. The underlying activity related to the procurement of land constituting stock-in-trade. Moreover, there was no actual forfeiture of the amount.
The substantial questions of law were accordingly answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. The Revenue’s appeal was dismissed without any order as to costs.
Key Legal Principle
Section 56(2)(ix) cannot be invoked merely because an advance remains outstanding for a prolonged period. The Revenue must establish that the amount was received during negotiations for the transfer of a capital asset, that it was actually forfeited, and that the negotiations did not culminate in the transfer of that asset.
Where funds are provided for carrying out a business activity involving stock-in-trade and continue to be acknowledged as liabilities, neither the age of the outstanding amount nor the absence of an immediate refund claim can convert the advance into taxable income.
Why This Judgment Matters
The decision provides important guidance for real estate businesses, land aggregators, developers and other taxpayers who receive advances for procuring or facilitating business assets. It clarifies that the character of a receipt must be determined from the underlying transaction and not merely from the period for which the amount remains outstanding.
The ruling also reinforces the distinction between a capital asset and stock-in-trade while applying Section 56(2)(ix). Assessing authorities must establish actual forfeiture through supporting material and cannot presume forfeiture solely from the passage of time.




