Home Case Laws Kerala HC Upholds Circular Relief for Bona Fide ITC Claims Prior to...

Kerala HC Upholds Circular Relief for Bona Fide ITC Claims Prior to 2022

0
326

Case Summary

Case Title:
Liz Enterprises & Others v. State of Kerala & Others

Court:
High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

Petition Numbers:
WP(C) No. 28287/2019, 10022/2021, 17111/2021, 22869/2022, 33952/2022, 34265/2022, 34761/2022, 35347/2022, 35606/2022, 35797/2022, 35980/2022, 37023/2022, 37908/2022, 41861/2022

Date of Judgment:
28th June 2024

Presiding Judge:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Dinesh Kumar Singh

Category of Dispute:
Input Tax Credit (ITC)

Relevant Sections:
Section 16(2)(c), 16(4), Section 39 of the CGST Act; Circular No.183/15/2022-GST & Circular No.193/05/2023-GST


Facts of the Case

(Para 1–2, 24)

  1. The batch of petitions involved three categories of assessees:

    • Suppliers who remitted GST but it did not reflect in GSTR due to technical errors.

    • Buyers who paid GST with valid invoices but suppliers failed to remit tax.

    • Buyers who possessed invoices but lacked proof of payment or actual receipt of goods.

  2. Petitioners challenged denial of ITC due to supplier non-compliance or delay in return filing, invoking hardship during GST rollout in FY 2017–18 and 2018–19.


Question(s) in Consideration

(Para 2, 99–100)

  1. Whether ITC can be denied to buyers when the suppliers defaulted in depositing tax?

  2. Whether procedural amendments to Section 39 allowing return filing till 30th November should apply retrospectively?

  3. Whether Circulars No.183/15/2022-GST and 193/05/2023-GST provide relief for bona fide ITC claims?


Observation of Court

(Para 99–100)

  1. The Court noted the GST system faced technical limitations in the initial rollout years; GSTR-2A was not available for FY 2017–18 and 2018–19.

  2. It acknowledged that Circulars 183 and 193 were meant to address such bona fide claims and that assessees should be allowed to submit proof of payment.

  3. The amendment to Section 39 (shifting return due date from 30th September to 30th November) was held procedural and to be applied retrospectively from 01.07.2017.

  4. The challenge to the constitutional validity of Sections 16(2)(c) and 16(4) was rejected.


Judgment of the Court

(Para 101–101.1)

  1. Petitioners were permitted to apply for ITC relief under the aforementioned Circulars within 30 days.

  2. GST authorities were directed to examine such claims and grant relief accordingly.

  3. Returns filed up to 30th November (instead of 30th September) from FY 2017–18 onward must be accepted for ITC claim if otherwise eligible.


Between Fine Lines

  • Relief has been granted for taxpayers who faced genuine hardships during the initial years of GST.

  • Procedural compliance timeline for GSTR-3B return extended retrospectively to 30th November.

  • Section 16(2)(c) and 16(4) remain constitutionally valid but are to be interpreted harmoniously with the Circulars.

  • GST officers must evaluate ITC eligibility under bona fide conditions, guided by CBIC Circulars.

  • Assessees must act within 30 days to benefit from this judgment.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
W.P.(C) No. 31559/2019 & Batch Kerala HC, 04.06.2024 Addressed same issue of ITC denial due to supplier non-payment; upheld Circular-based relief Relief granted if ITC claim within extended time
D.Y. Beathel Enterprises v. STO W.P.(MD) No. 2127/21 Madras HC held ITC can’t be denied without proceeding against supplier Relief granted to bona fide recipient

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY