Home Updates Kerala High Court Directs Grant of ITC Benefit Under Section 16(5) Despite...

Kerala High Court Directs Grant of ITC Benefit Under Section 16(5) Despite Section 16(4) Limitation

0
105

The Kerala High Court has granted relief to M/s Mobile City Communication in a dispute concerning denial of Input Tax Credit (ITC) on the ground that the relevant returns had not been filed within the time prescribed under Section 16(4) of the CGST Act.

The petitioner, a registered taxpayer under the CGST/KGST framework, challenged an Order-in-Original passed under Section 73 of the CGST Act. Under the impugned order, ITC relating to January, February and March 2019 had been denied because the returns were allegedly not furnished within the period stipulated under Section 16(4). A subsequent rectification application filed by the petitioner was also rejected.

Section 16(5) Relief Claimed by Taxpayer

Before the High Court, the petitioner relied upon Section 16(5) of the CGST Act, which provides a special relaxation in relation to availment of ITC for specified earlier financial years where the relevant return has been furnished within the extended statutory period contemplated by that provision.

The High Court noted from the Order-in-Original itself that the petitioner had furnished the relevant returns on 31 October 2019. On this basis, the Court found that the petitioner was entitled to have the benefit of Section 16(5) considered in relation to the disputed ITC.

Kerala High Court Quashes ITC Denial

The Court consequently quashed the Order-in-Original and the rectification rejection order to the extent they denied ITC solely for failure to file the returns within the period prescribed under Section 16(4).

The competent authority was directed to reconsider the matter and grant the petitioner the benefit of ITC on the strength of Section 16(5), provided the petitioner is otherwise eligible for such credit.

The judgment is significant for taxpayers whose ITC for earlier tax periods was rejected merely on limitation under Section 16(4), but whose claims may now fall within the statutory relaxation provided by Section 16(5).

Key Takeaway

Where a taxpayer satisfies the conditions contemplated under Section 16(5) of the CGST Act, an ITC claim cannot continue to be rejected solely by applying the original limitation contained in Section 16(4). Authorities are required to examine the taxpayer’s eligibility in light of the subsequent statutory relaxation.

The judgment, however, does not grant unconditional ITC. The High Court expressly made the relief subject to the petitioner being otherwise entitled to the credit under the GST law.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY