Home Case Laws Liability Beyond Show Cause Held Unsustainable Under Section 73

Liability Beyond Show Cause Held Unsustainable Under Section 73

0
266

Case Title: M/s. Duakem Pharma Private Limited & Anr.
Court: High Court at Calcutta
Petition Number: WPA 18295 of 2024
Category: Classification / Natural Justice / ITC Reversal
Date of Judgement: 10.04.2025
Relevant Sections: Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017
CGST Rules Referred: Not explicitly cited


🧾 Facts of the Case

(Relevant Paragraphs: 1–3)

  1. The petitioners challenged an order dated 29.04.2024 passed under Section 73 of the CGST/WBGST Act for FY 2018–19, which determined tax liability on the basis of outward supply values arising from inward supply of certain goods.

  2. The show cause notice dated 29.12.2023 primarily alleged ITC reversal to the extent of ₹14,07,127.84 (IGST) and ₹3,08,617.56 (CGST and SGST each) on account of exempt supplies.

  3. However, in the final order, the proper officer additionally imposed tax liability on assessable value of outward supplies derived from inward supplies of goods from Narmada Gelatines Ltd. and Alivira Animal Health Ltd., which were never mentioned in the show cause notice.


⚖️ Questions in Consideration

(Relevant Paragraphs: 2, 4)

  1. Whether the assessing authority could fasten liability on the basis of assessable value of outward supplies derived from inward supplies without having raised such issue in the show cause notice.

  2. Whether such liability determination violates principles of natural justice and exceeds the scope of the original notice under Section 73.


🔍 Observations of the Court

(Relevant Paragraphs: 4–5)

  1. The Court noted that the show cause notice confined itself to reversal of ITC on exempt supplies and did not allege taxability based on value of outward supplies derived from inward taxable goods.

  2. The tax demands of ₹13,27,328.40 (@12% on ₹2,21,22,140), ₹1,66,219.74 (@12% on ₹27,70,329), and ₹69,552.60 (@5% on ₹27,82,104) were found to be based on grounds not reflected in the show cause.

  3. The impugned order, therefore, was held to be in violation of principles of natural justice as it went beyond the original show cause and denied the petitioners an opportunity to be heard on such new grounds.


🧑‍⚖️ Judgement of the Court

(Relevant Paragraphs: 4–7)

  1. The additions made in the final order beyond the scope of the original show cause notice were set aside.

  2. Liberty was granted to the tax department to initiate fresh proceedings on those issues, if advised, in accordance with law.

  3. The period between the date of original order (29.04.2024) and date of this judgment (10.04.2025) or receipt of certified copy shall be excluded from limitation for initiation of such fresh proceedings.

  4. The writ petition was accordingly disposed of.


📌 Between Fine Lines:

  • A tax authority cannot impose additional liabilities beyond the scope of a show cause notice.

  • A show cause must explicitly state all grounds; otherwise, such additions violate natural justice.

  • The High Court set aside the impugned order to the extent it exceeded the show cause.

  • However, the department can restart proceedings afresh on the same issues.

  • Taxpayers must verify that all demands stem strictly from stated grounds in notices.


📚 Summary of Referred Cases:

Name Citation Summary Verdict
No specific case law N.A. The Court did not refer to any external precedent but applied principles of natural justice and the rule against widening scope beyond a SCN. N.A.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY