The Gujarat High Court in Loonchand Dhanraj HUF v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 5(3) has quashed reassessment proceedings initiated under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, holding that reopening an assessment on an issue already examined during the original scrutiny assessment amounted to an impermissible change of opinion. The judgment was delivered on 19 August 2026 by a Division Bench comprising Justice A.S. Supehia and Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati in R/Special Civil Application No. 18101 of 2019.
Background of the Case
For Assessment Year 2012-13, the petitioner had disclosed transactions involving shares of Prissm Remedies Pvt. Ltd. The return was subjected to scrutiny assessment under Section 143(3). During those proceedings, the Assessing Officer specifically sought details concerning the purchase and sale of the shares, their valuation, the lower sale price, supporting documents, share certificates, bank statements and valuation workings. The petitioner furnished detailed explanations and documents, following which the assessment order was passed on 9 March 2015.
Subsequently, a notice dated 29 March 2019 was issued under Section 148 seeking to reopen the assessment. The reassessment was based on information received from the Investigation Wing concerning the splitting of shares in the ratio of 1:10 and the consequent reduction in per-share value from ₹110 to ₹11. The Revenue alleged that a short-term capital loss of ₹3.066 crore claimed by the petitioner was not genuine.
Gujarat High Court’s Findings
The High Court examined the original scrutiny record and found that the very transaction forming the basis of the reassessment had already been specifically examined by the Assessing Officer. The petitioner had been called upon to explain why the shares were purchased at a higher price and subsequently sold at a substantially lower value, and had furnished the relevant documentary evidence and valuation details.
The Court observed that the reasons recorded for reopening were founded upon the same issue concerning the shares of Prissm Remedies Pvt. Ltd. that had been considered during the original assessment proceedings.
Accordingly, the Court held that reopening the assessment for the self-same reasons amounted to a mere change of opinion. Such reassessment is impermissible unless the Revenue demonstrates the existence of fresh tangible material indicating escapement of income and suppression of material facts by the assessee.
Decision
The Gujarat High Court allowed the writ petition and quashed both the Section 148 notice dated 29 March 2019 and the order dated 4 October 2019 disposing of the petitioner’s objections.
The judgment reiterates an important limitation on reassessment jurisdiction: where an issue has been specifically examined during scrutiny assessment after calling for and considering detailed information, the Assessing Officer cannot reopen the completed assessment merely because a different view is subsequently sought to be taken on the same material.




