Home Case Laws Mere postal/physical copy received instead of uploading into portal does not mean...

Mere postal/physical copy received instead of uploading into portal does not mean such reply will not be taken into consideration.

0
553

Case Title: Asia (Chennai) Engineering Company (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner (ST) (FAC)

Court: High Court of Madras

Petition No.: W.P.(MD) Nos. 13851 and 13870 of 2022

Category of Dispute: Refund – Erroneous Refund Claim

Date of Judgement: August 22, 2022

Relevant Sections: Section 75(4), 73(9), 74(9), 76(3), 169 of the CGST Act, 2017

Takeaway: Portal versus Post – When Mode of Reply Denies Natural Justice

 

Facts of the Case

(¶1, ¶2, ¶5)

  • A show cause notice (SCN) dated 30-11-2021 was issued to the petitioner to revoke an allegedly erroneous refund claim for the periods July 2017–March 2018 and April 2018–May 2018.
  • The petitioner submitted a hardcopy reply dated 07-01-2022, received by the department on 10-01-2022.
  • The adjudicating authority proceeded to pass an order on 31-03-2022 without considering the reply and claimed non-attendance in personal hearings dated 17-02-2022 and 16-03-2022.
  • Petitioner argued that the reply and request were submitted, but not reflected on the portal, and no genuine opportunity of personal hearing was afforded.

Questions in Consideration

(¶1, ¶3, ¶5)

  • Whether failure to submit a reply via GST portal invalidates a valid postal submission under Section 75(4)?
  • Whether personal hearing was mandatorily required before adverse order was passed?
  • Whether the denial of considering the physical reply amounts to violation of principles of natural justice?

 

Observations of the Court

(¶1, ¶2, ¶3, ¶5)

  • Under Section 75(4), when an adverse decision is contemplated, personal hearing is mandatory.
  • The use of “shall be furnished” in GST DRC-06 without the term “electronically” implies that physical replies are not precluded.
  • Though Section 169 permits service of notice via portal or email, it does not nullify a reply made physically, especially if duly received and acknowledged.
  • Petitioner’s reply was not disputed as being received on 10-01-2022; its non-consideration is a clear violation of natural justice.
  • The Court relied on precedent (W.P. No. 13652 of 2020) holding personal hearing necessary if any adverse view is taken.

 

Judgement of the Court

(¶6, ¶7)

  • The Court directed the second respondent (to whom the file was transferred) to grant a personal hearing to the petitioner.
  • The petitioner shall be allowed to submit documents and make representations.
  • Thereafter, the Department may proceed afresh in respect of both show cause notices.
  • Entire process to be completed within three months.
  • Writ Petitions were disposed of; no cost imposed.

Between Fine Lines

  • The GST Department cannot ignore a reply simply because it was submitted physically instead of electronically.
  • Section 75(4) mandates personal hearing before passing adverse orders.
  • Even registered taxpayers cannot be denied the right of representation through non-portal channels if such replies are acknowledged.
  • Natural justice requires that all valid submissions, regardless of medium, be considered before final adjudication.
  • This judgment reaffirms procedural fairness and limits portal-driven rigidity.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Unreported W.P. No. 13652 of 2020 Madras HC, 19-01-2021 Held that under Section 75(4) personal hearing is mandatory in all adverse cases Reinforced requirement of personal hearing

LEAVE A REPLY