Case Details
| Particulars | Details |
|---|---|
| Case | Mitsui Mining and Smelting Company Limited v. The Asst. CIT, Circle-2(2)(1), International Taxation, Delhi |
| Forum | Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench ‘D’, New Delhi |
| Coram | Shri Prakash Chand Yadav, Judicial Member and Shri Naveen Chandra, Accountant Member |
| Appeal No. | ITA No. 1407/Del/2025 |
| Assessment Year | 2022–23 |
| Date of Hearing | 15 July 2025 |
| Date of Pronouncement | 31 July 2025 |
| Relevant Provision | Article 5 of the India–Japan Tax Treaty |
| Decision | Appeal allowed in favour of the assessee |
Seconded Employees Do Not Create Fixed Place PE Without Control Over Premises
The Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has held that the secondment of employees by a Japanese company to its Indian subsidiary did not create a fixed place Permanent Establishment (“PE”) in India. The Tribunal found that the employees worked exclusively under the control and supervision of the Indian subsidiary and that the Japanese company had no right to use or exercise control over the subsidiary’s premises, assets or employees.
Background
Mitsui Mining and Smelting Company Limited is a non-resident company incorporated in Japan. It is engaged in businesses including the manufacture and sale of functional engineered materials, electronic materials, non-ferrous metal smelting, mineral resource development, precious-metal recycling and automotive components.
The company has an Indian subsidiary, Mitsui Kinzoku Components India Private Limited (“MKCI”), which manufactures and sells catalytic converters used in the automobile industry. The appellant also supplied certain precious metals and chemicals to MKCI through offshore sales.
During Assessment Year 2022–23, the appellant received royalty and fees for technical services from MKCI and offered those receipts to tax in India. It also received reimbursement of remuneration paid in Japan to expatriate employees seconded to MKCI. Part of the employees’ salaries was paid in India by MKCI, while the remaining portion was paid in Japan by the appellant and subsequently reimbursed by MKCI.
The Assessing Officer concluded that the seconded employees exercised control over the premises of MKCI and participated in its sales operations. On that basis, the Assessing Officer held that MKCI constituted a PE of the appellant in India under Article 5 of the India–Japan Tax Treaty. The Dispute Resolution Panel affirmed this conclusion.
Issue Before the Tribunal
The principal issue was whether the employees seconded to MKCI continued to be under the control of the Japanese appellant and whether their presence at MKCI’s premises created a fixed place PE of the appellant in India.
The appellant contended that a fixed place PE could arise only where a foreign enterprise had a fixed place at its disposal and carried on its own business through that place. It argued that neither condition was satisfied because MKCI exercised complete control over the seconded employees and the appellant had no right over MKCI’s premises.
Tribunal’s Findings
The Tribunal examined the secondment agreement dated 1 April 2019 and found that its terms did not support the conclusions reached by the Assessing Officer and the DRP.
Under the agreement, the seconded employees, referred to as “Shukko-sha,” were integrated into MKCI’s business as its own employees. Clause 4.1 stipulated that they would work as full-time employees of MKCI and exclusively under its control, direction, responsibility and supervision. Clause 4.2 further clarified that the employees would work in their personal capacity and not for or on behalf of the appellant.
The Tribunal also noted that MKCI was the sole controlling authority in relation to the employees’ services. Under Clause 5.5, the appellant was not responsible for any losses caused to MKCI by the actions of the seconded employees. Consequently, no vicarious liability rested upon the appellant.
Clause 5.6 further established that the appellant had no right to use, maintain or dispose of any structure or asset belonging to MKCI and had no right over MKCI’s employees.
On a cumulative reading of these provisions, the Tribunal found that the appellant neither controlled the seconded employees nor exercised control over the premises, assets or organisational structure of MKCI.
Conditions for a Fixed Place PE
The Tribunal observed that Article 5 of the India–Japan Tax Treaty requires the existence of a fixed place and the carrying on of the foreign enterprise’s business through that place. Both requirements are conditions precedent for treating a non-resident as having a fixed place PE in India.
Since the appellant had no place at its disposal in India and was not carrying on its own business through MKCI’s premises, these essential conditions were not satisfied. The mere supply or secondment of employees could not, in the circumstances of the case, create a fixed place PE.
Decision
The ITAT held that the Assessing Officer and the DRP had erred in treating the appellant as having a PE in India. The finding of a fixed place PE based on the seconded employees was therefore rejected, and the assessee’s appeal was allowed.
Although the assessee had also raised a ground concerning limitation, the operative reasoning decided the appeal on the PE issue and did not separately adjudicate the limitation ground.
Conclusion
The ruling emphasises that the creation of a fixed place PE depends upon the foreign enterprise having the relevant place at its disposal and carrying on its business through that place. Employee secondment, by itself, does not establish a fixed place PE where the Indian entity exercises exclusive control and supervision over the employees and the foreign enterprise has no right over the Indian entity’s premises or assets.




