The Karnataka High Court, in Ms Rajdeep Buildcon Pvt. Ltd. v. The Additional Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, delivered an important judgment clarifying the limits of the suo motu revisional powers exercised under Section 64 of the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (KVAT Act). The Court examined whether the revisional authority could interfere with reassessment orders after merely adopting a different interpretation despite the assessing authority having already considered the relevant material and taken a legally sustainable view. The decision also discusses the limitation applicable to revision proceedings and reiterates the statutory requirement that revisional jurisdiction can be exercised only when the impugned order is both erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue.
The appeals arose from reassessment proceedings relating to works contract deductions where the Suo Motu Revisional (SMR) Authority revised reassessment orders passed under the KVAT Act. The principal issues before the High Court included the scope of Section 64 revisional jurisdiction, the limitation applicable to such proceedings, and whether deductions claimed towards security charges, transportation charges and fuel expenses under Rule 3(2) of the Karnataka Value Added Tax Rules, 2005 were rightly allowed by the assessing authority.
The High Court reaffirmed that Section 64 can be invoked only when the order sought to be revised is both erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. Merely because the revisional authority prefers another possible interpretation does not justify interference. Where the assessing authority has examined the books of account, considered the evidence and adopted one legally permissible view, the revisional authority cannot exercise jurisdiction merely on a change of opinion. The Court relied upon the principles governing revisional jurisdiction laid down by the Supreme Court in Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. v. CIT.
The Court further analysed the limitation prescribed under Section 64 of the KVAT Act and held that calling for records within four years constitutes valid initiation of revisional proceedings. However, the revisional proceedings must ordinarily be concluded within a reasonable period and, in the statutory scheme of the KVAT Act, the final revisional order should generally be passed within five years from the order sought to be revised. Orders passed beyond this period were held to be unsustainable on the ground of limitation.
On the merits of the Rajdeep Buildcon appeals, the Court held that security charges, being manpower-related expenses incurred in connection with execution of works contracts, are covered by the expression “labour and other like charges” under Rule 3(2)(l) of the KVAT Rules. Similarly, transportation expenses and fuel expenses incurred in connection with execution of works contracts were also found to be deductible in accordance with the statutory provisions. Since the assessing authority had already examined these issues and adopted a legally permissible view, the revisional authority could not substitute its own opinion merely because another interpretation was possible. Consequently, the revisional orders were set aside in favour of the assessee.
This judgment is significant for contractors, VAT practitioners, tax litigators and businesses dealing with legacy KVAT matters. It provides valuable guidance on the limits of revisional jurisdiction, interpretation of labour-related deductions in works contracts, application of the twin conditions for revision, and the reasonable time within which revisional powers must be exercised.




