Home Updates ITAT Delhi Quashes Section 263 Revision in Mukul Rohatgi Case Over ALV...

ITAT Delhi Quashes Section 263 Revision in Mukul Rohatgi Case Over ALV of Properties

0
127

The Delhi Bench “F” of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has allowed the appeal of Shri Mukul Rohatgi and quashed the revisional order passed under Section 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 for Assessment Year 2022-23. The Tribunal examined both the jurisdictional validity of the revision proceedings and the merits of the Principal Commissioner’s objections concerning annual letting value (ALV) of various immovable properties.

Section 263 Notice Held Without Jurisdiction

A significant jurisdictional issue arose because the officer who initiated the revision proceedings had already been promoted to the rank of Chief Commissioner of Income Tax (CCIT). The Tribunal noted that CBDT Office Order No. 35 of 2026 dated 26 February 2026 provided that promoted officers would continue holding their earlier charge only until formal posting. The material before the Tribunal indicated that the concerned officer had joined the formal posting, yet the show-cause notice dated 27 February 2026 was issued using the designation of PCIT-12.

The Tribunal observed that although Section 263 permits a Chief Commissioner to exercise revisional powers, such jurisdiction must be exercised in the appropriate statutory capacity. If an officer is to discharge the functions of another income-tax authority, there must be an appropriate authorisation under Section 120(2). In the absence of such authority, the Tribunal held the impugned notice to be without jurisdiction and consequently quashed the revisional order.

The Tribunal relied on the principle that where a statute confers power upon a specified authority, the statutory requirement must be complied with in the prescribed manner. Reference was made, inter alia, to the decisions in SPL’s Siddhartha Ltd. and Ghanshyam K. Khabrani v. ACIT.

Revision Also Fails on Merits

The Tribunal independently examined the controversy on merits. The Assessing Officer had completed the assessment under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B after making inquiries regarding the assessee’s properties, their use and the treatment of ALV.

The PCIT sought to revise the assessment primarily on the ground that ALV ought to have been offered in respect of several properties situated at places including London, Goa, Mukteshwar and Dubai, apart from other properties referred to in the assessment records.

The Tribunal found that the Assessing Officer had sought information and the assessee had furnished relevant details during assessment proceedings. It therefore rejected the proposition that the assessment had been completed without inquiry or verification.

Properties Used for Profession and Section 22

An important principle emerging from the decision concerns properties used for professional purposes. The Tribunal held that where a property was genuinely utilised for carrying on the assessee’s profession, it could not be subjected to notional ALV merely because ALV had been offered for the property in earlier years.

The Tribunal referred to the principle under Section 22 that annual value is not chargeable under the head “Income from house property” where the property is occupied for the purposes of a business or profession whose profits are chargeable to income tax.

In relation to the London properties, the Tribunal noted their professional use and followed the view taken in the assessee’s own case for an earlier assessment year. Similar consideration was given to properties at Goa and Mukteshwar, while the Dubai property was stated to have been used for professional conferences and engagements. The property at Noida was separately noted as one in respect of which actual rental income had already been disclosed.

Prior Offering of ALV Does Not Create Estoppel

The Tribunal also observed that merely because the assessee had voluntarily offered ALV from certain properties in earlier assessment years, he could not be compelled to continue offering an amount that was otherwise not chargeable under the statute.

Accordingly, an earlier treatment adopted by the taxpayer did not prevent the correct legal position from being claimed in a subsequent year where the factual use of the property justified such treatment.

Adequate Inquiry Cannot Be Treated as “No Inquiry”

The Tribunal rejected the PCIT’s reliance on Explanation 2 to Section 263. It found that specific inquiries had already been undertaken by the Assessing Officer regarding the properties and their professional use.

The Tribunal emphasised that the PCIT had neither demonstrated what further inquiry ought to have been conducted nor brought independent material on record establishing that the Assessing Officer’s view was unsustainable. Where the Assessing Officer has examined the matter and adopted a plausible view, Section 263 cannot be invoked merely because the revisional authority prefers another view.

Gifted Properties

The Tribunal further considered properties transferred by way of gift to family members. It noted that properties which were no longer owned by the assessee could not ordinarily be treated as his properties for determining ALV merely on the basis that they had previously appeared in his records. The particular tax treatment nevertheless depended upon the statutory provisions discussed in the proceedings and the professional use of the properties concerned.

Decision

The ITAT ultimately held that the Section 263 proceedings failed on both grounds. First, the impugned notice suffered from a jurisdictional defect. Second, even on merits, the Assessing Officer had conducted adequate inquiry and adopted a legally plausible view regarding the properties.

The Tribunal held that the revision represented a mere change of opinion, and the PCIT had not established that the assessment order was both erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. The revisional order was therefore quashed and the assessee’s appeal was allowed.

Download

LEAVE A REPLY