The Uttarakhand High Court, in Naveen Kumar v. Commissioner Central Goods and Services Tax (Central Excise Appeal No. 07 of 2026, decided on 10 July 2026), has clarified an important issue relating to the mandatory pre-deposit required for filing appeals before the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT). The judgment addresses the manner in which the statutory pre-deposit under Section 35F of the Central Excise Act, 1944 is to be computed and whether the amount deposited at the first appellate stage should be taken into account while determining compliance before the Tribunal.
The appellant’s appeal before the Tribunal had been dismissed on the ground that the mandatory pre-deposit requirement had not been fulfilled. The Tribunal held that the amount deposited before the Commissioner (Appeals) could not be considered and that the appellant was required to comply independently with the statutory requirement before CESTAT. Before the High Court, however, the Revenue itself accepted that the earlier deposit made before the Commissioner (Appeals) forms part of the mandatory 10% pre-deposit and that a fresh deposit of 10% over and above the earlier 7.5% is not required.
Taking note of the Department’s stand and the CESTAT Circular dated 09.07.2018, the High Court set aside both the order of the Tribunal and that of the Commissioner (Appeals). The matter was remanded to the Commissioner (Appeals) for adjudication on merits, observing that once the statutory pre-deposit requirement stood satisfied, the appeal ought not to have been rejected merely on technical grounds. The Court, however, kept open the larger legal question regarding the applicability of Circular dated 24.06.2019 for determination in an appropriate future case.
This judgment reinforces the principle that procedural requirements relating to statutory pre-deposit should be interpreted in accordance with the statutory framework and applicable judicial interpretation rather than through an incorrect understanding of departmental instructions. It also underscores that appellate authorities should decide matters on merits once the mandatory conditions prescribed by law have been fulfilled.
Professionals handling GST, Central Excise and Service Tax litigation should carefully examine this decision, particularly in matters involving maintainability of appeals, computation of statutory pre-deposit, and interpretation of Section 35F. The ruling will be relevant for advocates, Chartered Accountants, tax consultants and businesses involved in appellate proceedings before the Commissioner (Appeals) and CESTAT.




