Home Case Laws No VAT on Extra Neutral Alcohol.

No VAT on Extra Neutral Alcohol.

0
719

Jain Distillery (P.) Ltd. v. State of U.P., High Court of Allahabad, WRIT TAX Nos. 378 of 2021 & batch, Category: Legislative Competence / GST vs VAT / Alcohol Taxation, Date of Judgement: 28.09.2021

Relevant Sections: Article 246A, Article 366(12A), Entry 54 List II, Entry 84 List I, Section 174(1)(i) UPGST Act, Section 4(4), Section 7(c), Section 74 UPVAT Act

Facts of the Case

[Para 1–15]
The petitioners (Jain Distillery and others) challenged the levy of UPVAT on sales of Extra Neutral Alcohol (ENA) post-GST implementation. They contended that ENA is industrial alcohol, not alcoholic liquor for human consumption and thus falls within the GST regime, not State VAT.
[Para 16–22]
Historically, UPVAT covered alcohol (excluding country liquor) under Schedule IV, and a 2008 notification exempted it from tax if excise was paid. However, in 2019, a new Notification (No. KA.NI-2-1793 dated 17.12.2019) reintroduced VAT at 5% on “non-GST alcohol” used in the manufacture of liquor for human consumption.

Questions in Consideration

[Para 2, 11, 56]

  1. Whether the State legislature retained the legislative competence to impose VAT on ENA after the 101st Constitution Amendment.
  2. Whether the impugned Notification dated 17.12.2019 and related assessment notices were valid.
  3. Whether ENA qualifies as “alcoholic liquor for human consumption” or remains a GST-covered commodity.

Observations of the Court

[Para 49–55]

  • ENA is highly pure ethyl alcohol (95%) and is unfit for human consumption unless processed further. Thus, ENA is industrial alcohol and not “alcoholic liquor for human consumption”.
  • ENA, though used to produce IMFL or country liquor, remains distinct from the final consumable product.
    [Para 56–60]
  • The 101st Constitution Amendment narrowed Entry 54 of List II to cover only 6 goods (including “alcoholic liquor for human consumption”) for State taxation.
  • The residual taxation power over other goods, including ENA, lies with the GST regime (Article 246A, Article 366(12A)).
    [Para 61–63]
  • Section 174(1)(i) of the UPGST Act repealed UPVAT except for the six listed commodities.
  • The impugned notification artificially coined the term “non-GST alcohol” without legislative basis and overreached constitutional limits.
    [Para 64–70]
  • Entry 8 of List II (intoxicating liquors) is a general entry and cannot support a tax law unless backed by a specific taxing entry.
  • Past precedents (Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd., Modi Distillery, Ajanta Bottlers) confirm States cannot tax ENA.
    [Para 71–72]
  • The court rejected the State’s argument that it can tax ENA under Entry 8.
  • State’s imposition of GST and VAT on the same transaction is impermissible and may require refund due to double taxation.

Judgement of the Court

[Para 73–75]

  • The High Court declared that the State of U.P. lost legislative competence to impose VAT on ENA post-101st Amendment.
  • The 2019 Notification and related assessments/circulars were quashed as ultra vires.
  • Refund of any UPVAT collected on ENA post-1.7.2017 was directed (subject to the rule against unjust enrichment).
  • All writ petitions were allowed; no costs awarded.

Between Fine Lines

  • ENA is not “alcoholic liquor for human consumption” and thus falls under GST.
  • Post-GST, State governments cannot impose VAT on ENA through backdoor notifications.
  • Use-based tax classification without physical transformation is invalid.
  • Entry 8 of List II can’t support tax laws without a corresponding taxing entry.
  • Refunds may be claimed where UPVAT was wrongly collected on ENA.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of U.P. (1990) 1 SCC 109 Held States can only tax alcoholic liquor “for human consumption”, not industrial alcohol. Upheld – ENA not taxable by States
State of U.P. v. Modi Distillery (1995) 5 SCC 753 Excise duty cannot be imposed on raw alcohol before it becomes potable. Upheld – State cannot tax ENA
Deccan Sugar & Abkari Co. Ltd. v. C.Ex. (2004) 1 SCC 243 Reiterated Synthetics judgment, holding States can’t tax industrial alcohol. Followed – States lack power
Ajanta Bottlers & Blenders (P.) Ltd. (2019) 7 SCC 545 Clarified stages of alcohol transformation; ENA is not consumable in current form. Followed – ENA not human-consumable
State of Bihar v. Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan (2005) 2 SCC 762 State can regulate if diversion to human consumption occurs. Distinguished – regulatory power only
State of A.P. v. McDowell & Co. (1996) 3 SCC 709 Entry 8 List II does not override other entries; used for prohibition laws. Affirmed – No tax power inferred
M.P.V. Sundararamier & Co. v. State of A.P. AIR 1958 SC 468 Taxing laws must derive from specific taxing entries, not general ones. Applied – General entry not enough
Navnit Lal C. Javeri v. K.K. Sen AIR 1965 SC 1375 Entry to be interpreted broadly, but only within rational limits. Distinguished – not relevant here

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY