Jain Distillery (P.) Ltd. v. State of U.P., High Court of Allahabad, WRIT TAX Nos. 378 of 2021 & batch, Category: Legislative Competence / GST vs VAT / Alcohol Taxation, Date of Judgement: 28.09.2021
Relevant Sections: Article 246A, Article 366(12A), Entry 54 List II, Entry 84 List I, Section 174(1)(i) UPGST Act, Section 4(4), Section 7(c), Section 74 UPVAT Act
Facts of the Case
[Para 1–15]
The petitioners (Jain Distillery and others) challenged the levy of UPVAT on sales of Extra Neutral Alcohol (ENA) post-GST implementation. They contended that ENA is industrial alcohol, not alcoholic liquor for human consumption and thus falls within the GST regime, not State VAT.
[Para 16–22]
Historically, UPVAT covered alcohol (excluding country liquor) under Schedule IV, and a 2008 notification exempted it from tax if excise was paid. However, in 2019, a new Notification (No. KA.NI-2-1793 dated 17.12.2019) reintroduced VAT at 5% on “non-GST alcohol” used in the manufacture of liquor for human consumption.
Questions in Consideration
[Para 2, 11, 56]
- Whether the State legislature retained the legislative competence to impose VAT on ENA after the 101st Constitution Amendment.
- Whether the impugned Notification dated 17.12.2019 and related assessment notices were valid.
- Whether ENA qualifies as “alcoholic liquor for human consumption” or remains a GST-covered commodity.
Observations of the Court
[Para 49–55]
- ENA is highly pure ethyl alcohol (95%) and is unfit for human consumption unless processed further. Thus, ENA is industrial alcohol and not “alcoholic liquor for human consumption”.
- ENA, though used to produce IMFL or country liquor, remains distinct from the final consumable product.
[Para 56–60] - The 101st Constitution Amendment narrowed Entry 54 of List II to cover only 6 goods (including “alcoholic liquor for human consumption”) for State taxation.
- The residual taxation power over other goods, including ENA, lies with the GST regime (Article 246A, Article 366(12A)).
[Para 61–63] - Section 174(1)(i) of the UPGST Act repealed UPVAT except for the six listed commodities.
- The impugned notification artificially coined the term “non-GST alcohol” without legislative basis and overreached constitutional limits.
[Para 64–70] - Entry 8 of List II (intoxicating liquors) is a general entry and cannot support a tax law unless backed by a specific taxing entry.
- Past precedents (Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd., Modi Distillery, Ajanta Bottlers) confirm States cannot tax ENA.
[Para 71–72] - The court rejected the State’s argument that it can tax ENA under Entry 8.
- State’s imposition of GST and VAT on the same transaction is impermissible and may require refund due to double taxation.
Judgement of the Court
[Para 73–75]
- The High Court declared that the State of U.P. lost legislative competence to impose VAT on ENA post-101st Amendment.
- The 2019 Notification and related assessments/circulars were quashed as ultra vires.
- Refund of any UPVAT collected on ENA post-1.7.2017 was directed (subject to the rule against unjust enrichment).
- All writ petitions were allowed; no costs awarded.
Between Fine Lines
- ENA is not “alcoholic liquor for human consumption” and thus falls under GST.
- Post-GST, State governments cannot impose VAT on ENA through backdoor notifications.
- Use-based tax classification without physical transformation is invalid.
- Entry 8 of List II can’t support tax laws without a corresponding taxing entry.
- Refunds may be claimed where UPVAT was wrongly collected on ENA.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of U.P. | (1990) 1 SCC 109 | Held States can only tax alcoholic liquor “for human consumption”, not industrial alcohol. | Upheld – ENA not taxable by States |
| State of U.P. v. Modi Distillery | (1995) 5 SCC 753 | Excise duty cannot be imposed on raw alcohol before it becomes potable. | Upheld – State cannot tax ENA |
| Deccan Sugar & Abkari Co. Ltd. v. C.Ex. | (2004) 1 SCC 243 | Reiterated Synthetics judgment, holding States can’t tax industrial alcohol. | Followed – States lack power |
| Ajanta Bottlers & Blenders (P.) Ltd. | (2019) 7 SCC 545 | Clarified stages of alcohol transformation; ENA is not consumable in current form. | Followed – ENA not human-consumable |
| State of Bihar v. Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan | (2005) 2 SCC 762 | State can regulate if diversion to human consumption occurs. | Distinguished – regulatory power only |
| State of A.P. v. McDowell & Co. | (1996) 3 SCC 709 | Entry 8 List II does not override other entries; used for prohibition laws. | Affirmed – No tax power inferred |
| M.P.V. Sundararamier & Co. v. State of A.P. | AIR 1958 SC 468 | Taxing laws must derive from specific taxing entries, not general ones. | Applied – General entry not enough |
| Navnit Lal C. Javeri v. K.K. Sen | AIR 1965 SC 1375 | Entry to be interpreted broadly, but only within rational limits. | Distinguished – not relevant here |




