Home Case Laws Non-Consideration of SCN Reply Vitiates Tax Order: Gauhati HC Remands Matter

Non-Consideration of SCN Reply Vitiates Tax Order: Gauhati HC Remands Matter

0
180

Case Details:

Case Title: M/s Assam Auto Spares v. State of Assam
Court: Gauhati High Court
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 1918 of 2024
Category of Dispute: Natural Justice – Reply to SCN Ignored
Date of Judgement: 05 June 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 73, 75(4), and 75(5) of CGST Act, 2017


Facts of the Case [¶2, ¶3, ¶5, ¶8]:

  • A show cause notice (SCN) was issued to the petitioner by the Deputy Commissioner, Guwahati Zone-B on 30.09.2023.

  • The petitioner filed an online reply to the SCN on 20.12.2023, acknowledged via ARN ZD18 1223033093T.

  • Despite this, on 29.12.2023, an order was passed confirming tax liability, with an observation that no reply had been filed. An attachment order was also passed the same day.

  • The petitioner challenged this order on the ground that their SCN reply was not considered.


Question(s) in Consideration [¶3, ¶7]:

  • Whether the impugned tax order and attachment passed on 29.12.2023 suffers from violation of principles of natural justice, given that the petitioner’s reply to SCN was submitted but not considered?


Observations of the Court [¶6, ¶7, ¶8]:

  • The impugned order erroneously states: “The taxpayer has not replied or contested the notice, deemed agreed with the terms of the notice.”

  • The respondent in its affidavit later admitted that the reply was received and considered, but this contradicts the order’s text.

  • The Court held that the authority could not retroactively justify its action via affidavit. What matters is what was recorded in the impugned order itself.

  • There was a clear denial of the petitioner’s right to be heard as mandated under Section 75(4) of the CGST Act.


Judgement of the Court [¶9, ¶10]:

  • The impugned order dated 29.12.2023 and the subsequent attachment order are quashed.

  • The matter is remanded to the Deputy Commissioner to pass a fresh order after considering the petitioner’s reply in accordance with the law.


Between Fine Lines:

  • Courts will not tolerate mechanical tax orders that overlook replies to SCNs.

  • Authorities must record reasons and show application of mind, not just presume agreement due to silence.

  • Once a reply is submitted and acknowledged, ignoring it breaches Section 75(4) of the CGST Act.

  • Affidavits cannot cure procedural lapses recorded in an order.

  • Natural justice is not a formality—it is mandatory in quasi-judicial proceedings.


Summary of Referred Cases:

Name Citation Summary Verdict
None cited explicitly in this judgment. – – –

LEAVE A REPLY