Case Title: Axrecycle (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner Mobile Aquad
Court: High Court of Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 712 of 2024
Relevant Section: Section 129(3) of the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: E-Way Bill Penalty
Date of Judgement: 07 May 2024
Relevant Legal Provisions: Section 129(3) of the UP GST Act, Article 226 of the Constitution of India
Facts of the Case
[Para 2, 3]
- The petitioner challenged the penalty order dated 22.12.2021 and the appellate rejection dated 20.01.2022, both passed under Section 129(3) of the UP GST Act.
- The penalty was imposed solely for the non-filling of Part-B of the e-Way Bill.
- It was undisputed that:
- The invoice contained the truck number;
- The goods matched the invoice;
- No intent to evade tax was demonstrated by the petitioner.
Questions in Consideration
[Para 3, 4]
- Whether mere non-filling of Part-B of the e-Way Bill without any evidence of tax evasion or mens rea is sufficient to impose penalty under Section 129(3) of the UP GST Act?
Observations of the Court
[Para 6, 7, 8]
- The Court noted similarities with the precedent Citykart Retail (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner Commercial Tax and VSL Alloys (India) (P.) Ltd. v. State of U.P., where it was held that such technical lapses without malafide intention do not justify penalty.
- The presence of truck details in the invoice and absence of tax evasion intention indicated a technical breach.
- The department failed to demonstrate any mens rea or wilful intent to evade tax.
Judgement of the Court
[Para 9]
- The High Court quashed the penalty and appellate orders dated 22.12.2021 and 20.01.2022 respectively.
- The writ petition was allowed.
- The respondents were directed to return the security to the petitioner within six weeks.
Between Fine Lines
- Mere technical lapse in e-Way Bill Part-B without any evasion intent does not attract penalty.
- Courts are recognizing intent as a critical element in such matters.
- If goods match the invoice and the transporter details are on record, penalties are unsustainable.
- Mens rea remains an essential precondition under Section 129(3) for penalty.
- Procedural mistakes, in absence of tax loss or fraud, do not warrant punitive action.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| VSL Alloys (India) (P.) Ltd. v. State of U.P. | [2018] 93 taxmann.com 119 / 67 GST 688 / 17 GSTL 191 / 2018 NTN [Vol.67]-1 | Held that mere non-filling of Part-B without evasion intent does not justify penalty under GST. | Penalty quashed. |
| Citykart Retail (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner Commercial Tax | [2022] 144 taxmann.com 155 / 2023 U.P.T.C. [Vol.113]-173 | Found that absence of Part-B in e-Way Bill is a procedural lapse if there is no tax evasion. | Orders quashed and relief granted. |
Takeaway:
“Intent Matters: Procedural lapse without tax evasion not penal under GST”




