Home Case Laws Notice under Section 17(5) quashed; case remanded as functionality test must determine...

Notice under Section 17(5) quashed; case remanded as functionality test must determine whether school building qualifies as “plant” under GST.

0
278

Case Title: M/s SBS Schooling Faridkot v. State of Punjab & Others
Court: High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh
Petition No.: CWP-22846-2024 (O&M)
Date of Judgment: 28 November 2024
Category: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Blocked Credits under Section 17(5)
Relevant Sections: Sections 16(4), 17(5)(c), and 17(5)(d) of the CGST Act, 2017; Clauses (2) and (5) of Schedule II

Facts (Para 1–2)

M/s SBS Schooling Faridkot filed a writ petition challenging the vires of Section 17(5)(c) and 17(5)(d) of the Central and Punjab GST Acts, 2017, which restrict the availment of Input Tax Credit (ITC) on construction of immovable property. The petitioner contended that their educational building should be treated as a “plant” since it was essential to the business of providing educational services, thereby entitling them to ITC on its construction.


Questions before the Court (Para 1–2)

The primary question was whether the bar on ITC under Section 17(5)(c) and (d) could apply to buildings used in providing taxable services, and whether such buildings could qualify as “plant or machinery” under Section 17(5)(d).


Observations (Para 2)

The Court noted that the Supreme Court in Chief Commissioner of Central Goods and Service Tax v. Safari Retreats (P.) Ltd., [2024] 167 taxmann.com 73 (SC) had already settled the issue. The Apex Court held:

  • The constitutional validity of Sections 17(5)(c), 17(5)(d), and 16(4) was upheld.

  • However, “plant or machinery” in Section 17(5)(d) is not identical to its definition in the Explanation to Section 17.

  • The functionality test must be applied to determine if a building (other than a hotel or cinema) qualifies as a “plant.”

  • If the construction is essential to the taxpayer’s business — e.g., leasing, renting, or similar activities under Schedule II — such building could be treated as “plant,” thereby allowing ITC.

Relying on this, the High Court observed that the petitioner’s case required examination under the functionality test, as directed by the Supreme Court.


Judgment (Para 3–5)

The High Court held that the issue was no longer res integra post-Safari Retreats and that the facts of the petitioner’s case must be re-examined by the department. Consequently:

  • The notice in Form GST ASMT-10 dated 17.07.2024 was set aside.

  • The matter was remanded to the respondents to conduct a fresh examination applying the functionality test.

  • The department was directed to issue a speaking order after affording an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner.

  • The writ petition was partly allowed, and all pending applications were disposed of.


Summary of Cases Referred

Case Court & Citation Key Issue Verdict / Relevance
Chief Commissioner of CGST v. Safari Retreats (P.) Ltd. Supreme Court, [2024] 167 taxmann.com 73 (SC) Constitutional validity of Section 17(5)(c) & (d); ITC on building construction Upheld validity; introduced functionality test to determine when building qualifies as “plant,” allowing ITC in such cases.

Between Fine Lines

The judgment underscores that ITC on building construction cannot be automatically denied. If the construction directly supports the taxpayer’s core business — for instance, in education, leasing, or hospitality — it may qualify as a “plant” based on the functionality test. Taxpayers should be prepared to demonstrate the functional necessity of such buildings in their business operations when claiming ITC.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY