Home Case Laws Opportunity of Hearing Restored Despite Pending Challenge to GST Notifications

Opportunity of Hearing Restored Despite Pending Challenge to GST Notifications

0
208

Case Title: Shri Enterprises v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 3806/2025 & CM Appl. 17729/2025
Date of Judgement: 23rd April, 2025
Relevant Section: Section 73, Section 168A, CGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Validity of Notifications & Opportunity of Hearing (Natural Justice)


Facts of the Case

  1. [Para 2] Petitioner Shri Enterprises challenged Show Cause Notice (SCN) dated 10.12.2023 issued for FY 2018–19 and the consequential order dated 13.04.2024 under Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017.

  2. [Para 3] Petitioner also challenged CBIC Notifications No. 9/2023 dated 31.03.2023 and No. 56/2023 dated 28.12.2023 extending limitation under Section 168A.

  3. [Paras 6–7] Petitioner argued that due to ill health of its proprietor, neither a reply to the SCN could be filed nor the personal hearing could be attended, leading to an ex parte order.

  4. [Para 8] Demand was raised without Petitioner’s representation, violating principles of natural justice.


Questions in Consideration

  1. [Paras 4–5] Whether Notifications No. 9/2023 and 56/2023 issued under Section 168A were valid, when their recommendation/ratification by GST Council was in dispute.

  2. [Paras 6–8] Whether an ex parte order passed without reply or personal hearing could be sustained.

  3. [Paras 10–11] Whether the Petitioner should be given a fresh opportunity to contest on merits.


Observation of the Court

  1. [Paras 4–7] Multiple High Courts had taken conflicting stands on the validity of Notifications 9/2023 and 56/2023. The matter is pending before the Supreme Court in SLP No. 4240/2025 (M/s HCC-SEW-MEIL-AAG JV v. ACST).

  2. [Paras 6–7] Since the Petitioner could not reply to SCN or attend the hearing due to health issues, denial of hearing amounted to violation of natural justice.

  3. [Para 10] A fair opportunity must be given before raising demands and imposing penalties.


Judgement of the Court

  1. [Para 11] The impugned order dated 13.04.2024 was set aside.

  2. [Para 11] Petitioner granted 30 days to file reply to SCN; Adjudicating Authority to issue fresh hearing notice on provided email and mobile.

  3. [Para 12] Fresh order to be passed after considering Petitioner’s reply and hearing.

  4. [Para 13] The validity of Notifications 9/2023 & 56/2023 kept open, subject to outcome of Supreme Court’s decision.

  5. [Para 14] Petition disposed with these directions.


Between Fine Lines

  • Delhi HC restored Shri Enterprises’ right to hearing.

  • Notifications 9/2023 & 56/2023 under Section 168A are sub judice before SC.

  • Ex parte demand orders cannot stand if no opportunity of hearing is given.

  • Petitioner given 30 days to respond and attend fresh hearing.

  • Future outcome depends on Supreme Court ruling.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
DJST Traders Pvt. Ltd. v. UOI W.P.(C) 16499/2023 (Delhi HC) Lead matter challenging Notifications 9/2023 & 56/2023 Pending consideration
M/s HCC-SEW-MEIL-AAG JV v. ACST SLP No. 4240/2025 (SC) Challenge to validity of Section 168A notifications Pending before SC
Various Writs (Punjab & Haryana HC) Order 12.03.2025 Declined to rule; directed matters to be governed by SC Interim relief continued
Telangana HC Ruling Not specified Observed invalidity of Notification 56/2023 Under challenge in SC
Allahabad HC Not specified Upheld validity of Notification 9/2023 Notification sustained
Patna HC Not specified Upheld Notification 56/2023 Notification sustained
Guwahati HC Not specified Quashed Notification 56/2023 Notification invalid

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY